I *did* see it during its original run, and I remain perplexed why it ran so long. But then I have the same question about PHANTOM and LES MIZ. None of these three are especially wonderful. They all have mediocre scores, save for a few high points.. but "Memory" was pretty much the "Theme from Titanic" of its day, waaaaaaaaaaaaaay overplayed no matter where you went.
Yes, the choreography was wonderful and the set/costume/makeup design was outstanding, but as a production, it really is in the "why?" category.
Just as side note, I saw the MUNY production a couple of years back. The MUNY *is* a huge stage, one of the largest outdoor faciities in the US, and you would think that CATS woud be tailor made for such a stage. Normally, the MUNY productions are pretty good, but this one just seemed to underlne everything essentially wrong with the show. I couldnt wait for the damn tire to ascend.
http://docandraider.com