*very minor spoilers*
Saw this tonight and though I wasn't completely bowled over, I very very much enjoyed it. The staging is creative, simple, inspired, and complicated all at once. Really wonderfully done. I absolutely loved the inclusion of the band at the appropriate moments and everything felt very thoughtfully considered.
The ensemble as a whole is doing great work; each and every member playing multiple, and distinct characters to great effect. And their everyman-ness gave the entire evening an air of authenticity. Great casting. And I just loved the general celebratory tone of selflessness, being present, and collaboration.
I did feel a bit of "sameness" across the score and most of it didn't catch my ear as being interesting enough for repeat listening, but I think it was extremely appropriate and the storytelling was effective. Also I just found some lyrical moments to be a bit clunky and/or unimaginative, but really these are minor quibbles, the band played it with gusto and I was toe-tapping away.
I struggled with the lightness throughout the first half hour or so. I very much agree with Whizzer's comment that they did a wonderful job at avoiding manipulation, but I think it could have used just a touch more of the devastation of the reality of the situation just for shade and contrast. Eventually, I just allowed myself to get swept up in the story they set out to tell and it won me over. I also found a few of the characters and the humor to live just a teensy bit in caricature and stereotype, just here and there. The actual story is so utterly fascinating, I just wanted to know more about how this town was coping with the situation and less silly "sexy-tary" jokes.
And it did feel like they were trying to touch on a few too many topics at once. Does Jen Colella's song, which had a wonderful reveal about how the events of 9/11 made her feel differently, even if briefly, about the greatest thing in her life (flying), also need to be a anthem for gender equality? Believe me, I believe in everything said, but as a piece of storytelling in this instance, it felt a bit superfluously relevant. (Boy did she sound great though, and the character's journey is wonderful, I just think the moment would have been more effective as a more simple meditation on her relationship to flying.)
Those things I may have done differently said, overall, this is one of the more unique, engrossing, and delightfully staged shows I've seen in a while and I'm very pleased to have seen it.
"...and in a bed."