There have been rumors of Kyle Dean and Claybourne Elder as Andy. I think posting that is definitely a hint.
Maybe Elder is Andy and Kyle Dean is PJ?
Chorus Member Joined: 11/10/17
First casting announcement! Matt Doyle as Jamie and Etai Benson as Paul!!!
Per the show's instagram, Matt Doyle and Etai Benson have been officially announced as Jamie and Paul!
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/18/19
I wonder who will replace Jennifer in Mean Girls...
magictodo123 said: "I wonder who will replace Jennifer in Mean Girls..."
...somebody knows something...
https://broadwaynews.com/2019/10/21/matt-doyle-jennifer-simard-and-more-join-cast-of-company
Updated On: 10/21/19 at 08:26 AM
“Joining Katrina Lenk, playing Bobbie, and Patti LuPone as Joanne, are Matt Doyle as Jamie (known as Amy in the original production), Etai Benson as Paul, Christopher Sieber as Harry and Jennifer Simard as his wife, Sarah.
Christopher Fitzgerald will play David, opposite Nikki Renée Daniels as Jenny. Terence Archie will play Larry to LuPone’s Joanne. Greg Hildreth will play Peter to a Susan to be announced.
As Bobbie’s lovers, Claybourne Elder will play Andy (April in the original production), with Kyle Dean Massey as Theo (previously Kathy) and Bobby Conte Thornton as P.J. (previously Marta).”
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/18/19
Okay I keep re-reading the casting announcement and I just can't get over how amazing the cast is. WOW.
Kind of disappointing Kyle Dean is playing such a tiny role.
This cast. Wow! I can't wait for March 2!
I'm having palpitations over this cast. Now I feel even better about springing for front mezzanine seats.
Could Nikki Renee Daniels be covering Bobbie?! The Jenny track covered Bobbie in London!
Updated On: 10/21/19 at 08:57 AM
Even with Patti I was still not planning to see it. Still not crazy about the gender changes. Then when they announced Lenk I got interested. Now I know I won't be able to resist!
I crapped when I saw this cast list.
The men playing Bobbie’s love interests are all remarkably attractive eye candy and I am HERE FOR IT.
This is an incredible cast.
ljay889 said: "Kind of disappointing Kyle Dean is playing such a tiny role."
I had the same reaction. I was hoping he'd play PJ (Marta) so at least he'd sing "Another Hundred People." I'm not too familiar with Bobby Conte Thornton since I never watched A Bronx Tale.
Looking forward to see how Matt Doyle interprets "Getting Married Today." I saw this revival twice in London and Jonathan Bailey was the highlight of the show for me.
NEW CAST ABLUM 👏🏽 NEW CAST ALBUM 👏🏽 NEW CAST ALBUM
I think a new cast album is pretty much a guarantee. Can’t wait.
Interesting the casting announcement called this "Not a replica" of the London production and "some changes". Wonder how drastic they will end up being if they announced it
Broadway Star Joined: 6/15/17
I was already excited for this show, but this casting announcement is the cherry on top. Cannot wait for spring!
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/26/19
uncageg said: "Even with Patti I was still not planning to see it. Still not crazy about the gender changes. Then when they announced Lenk I got interested. Now I know I won't be able to resist!"
Same. Katrina Lenk is irresistible.
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/18/19
I am definitely getting tickets ASAP. GAH this cast!!
My goodness, this cast is Gold!!! Makes me even more excited to see it. Wonder what the delay is in casting the role of Susan?
Sad we won't get Jonathan Bailey's knockout star turn as Jamie, but I've no doubt Matt Doyle will be wonderful.
Kind of disappointing Kyle Dean is playing such a tiny role.
If he plays Andy anything like Richard Fleeshman did in London, you won't be disappointed in the least. Of the males in the cast, the character of Andy was second only to Jamie in being the most memorable performance.
Interesting the casting announcement called this "Not a replica" of the London production and "some changes".
I do find that a tiny bit worrisome as I thought the London production was perfection. The staging was absolutely brilliant. There were a couple of set reveals that I thought were jaw-dropping.
Videos