Is he a little old to play it convincingly? Yes, absolutely. However makeup does wonders. There was no way the producers were going to deny Platt the chance to get that EGOT title. It's one thing to play younger on stage, then to have the camera up close and all up in your face in HD, on the big screen like it will be on film. I would have much preferred a younger, undiscovered performer, but this is the casting we all knew was inevitable.
While think Platt is overhyped in every sense of the word, I think he will be good as he proved when he played the role on stage, I am excited for Moore and Pino. I'm big fans of both of them!
Darreyl with an L!