‘Ginger Twinsies’ Review: Loud, Crude, and Exhaustingly Unfunny
Off-Broadway’s Ginger Twinsies wants to be a clever parody of The Parent Trap—but instead, it’s a chaotic, painfully self-aware mess that mistakes volume for comedy and nostalgia for substance.
Writer-director Kevin Zak’s one-act spoof, now playing at the Orpheum Theatre, leans so heavily on millennial sentimentality and 1990s pop culture references that anyone outside the 29-to-44 demo will likely feel locked out—and those within it may just feel embarrassed. The premise is simple: grown adults Aneesa Folds and Russell Daniels, who look absolutely nothing alike, play the iconic redheaded twins once portrayed by Lindsay Lohan. The gag wears thin within minutes.
The show barrels forward with manic energy and a screeching cast that leaves no room for nuance. Every joke is bellowed with the subtlety of a jackhammer. What’s meant to be irreverent farce quickly devolves into a 90-minute shouting match where actors seem more like caffeinated camp counselors than skilled comedians.
There’s some skill here, buried under all the noise. Phillip Taratula does manage to wring some laughs as a cartoonish version of the villainous Meredith, and Jimmy Ray Bennett’s deadpan shifts between characters offer brief relief. But these moments are fleeting and drowned out by the overall chaos.
The staging is cheap and cluttered, with Beowulf Boritt’s juvenile set design looking like it was crafted for a third-grade history fair. Crayola Big Ben and all.
By the time the cast hits its stride—somewhere around the halfway mark—you’ll be too exhausted to care. Jokes about Whitney Houston, Village People, and a string of increasingly desperate sexual innuendos try to liven things up, but mostly just feel forced and oddly mean-spirited.
In the end, Ginger Twinsies isn’t so much a parody as it is a sugar-high meltdown. It plays like a college sketch comedy show that never grew up. For a production that prides itself on energy, the result is surprisingly lifeless. Even nostalgia has its limits.
Save your money—and your eardrums.