One word: SUPERB. Ab-so-lute-ly SUPERB. I enjoyed this sooooo much more the second time around, even though I’m sure Joseph Morales of the Philip Tour spoiled it for me. Loved him.
But this performance was in a slightly smaller theater than when I saw it last year at the State Theater in Cleveland (nearly 3200 seats there as compared to 2800 at the Benedum Center), and my seat was closer. That probably had quite a bit to do with it too.
The Angelica Cast was wonderful, and the powerhouse of the cast, for me at least, was Stephanie Umoh as Angelica Schuyler. She was simply impressive.
Next in order would be Bryson Bruce as Marquis de Lafayette / Thomas Jefferson; Josh Tower as Aaron Burr; Hannah Cruz as Eliza; Austin Scott as Alexander; and Paul Oakley Stovall as George Washington. And of course, Peter Matthew Smith, who played King George, was also amazing.
The audience reaction was so much more fresh and noticeable than when I saw “Hamilton” last year, with numerous rounds of thunderous applause, dead silence in the most emotional moments, and lots and lots of bursts of laughter and giggles at the countless sarcastic bits scattered all through the show.
My favorite song still has to be “Yorktown”, with some of the most impressive visuals and soaring vocals. It was so breathtaking it sent chills over my entire body.
I was also more emotionally involved this time, and caught myself tearing up several times, especially when Philip died, during “Burn”, “Hurricane”, and “It’s Quiet Uptown”.
But as superb as this show was, it wasn’t without issues.
I do wish Austin Scott (Alexander) and Hannah Cruz (Eliza) put a little more volume into their songs, especially in the first half of Act 1. There were times when, as we’ve discussed in another thread, diction, enunciation, delivery, timing, and articulation are all so very important. I’m glad that I have listened to the OBCR a hundred times, because there were moments when the orchestra was louder than the vocals and my brain filled in the lyrics I couldn’t hear or decipher them from the cast.
I did talk to several people in the souvenir line and the bathroom line at intermission, and on the way back to the parking garage: all were first timers to the show. They all said that they absolutely loved the show, but did have to lean-in and focus a lot on the lyrics, which one guy compared to Shakespeare.
I bought a crapload of souvenirs, some to replace ones I had bought in Cleveland and had given to the fantastic neighbor kids across the street. The neighbor’s budding 12-year old theater fan was also the recipient tonight of a “Hamilton” window card. She gasped with sheer joy when I surprised her with it. I had to buy these window cards because they were specific to the Benedum Center.
Overall, even with the issues mentioned, I had an absolutely glorious time. I left the theater still sniffling from the ending of “The World Was Wide Enough”, it was so magnificently done. Very emotional.
Can’t wait to see this again at some point in the very near future.
Here’s a link to some of the pictures I took:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/57377062@N04/albums/72157701913462832