It sounds pretty good!
For what will finally be his Broadway debut as a composer, Manilow has written a pleasant, digestible score that blends his signature tunefulness with surprisingly effective storytelling. An expositional opening number that melodically brings to mind La Cage aux Folles, a dramatic Menken-esque tearjerker later in Act One (with a terrific money note at the end) that already seems worthy of a mid-show ovation, the songs of love and special things he once mentioned all those decades ago — Barry does it all in just an hour of hummable music.
Act Two gets off to a lighthearted start before it takes a heavier turn. The Latin groove of "We're Goin' Loco!" provides a familiar echo of "Copacabana," while "Hungarian Rhapsody #20" shows off the comedy chops of the Comedian Harmonists with a medley that includes snippets of "Galop Infernal," "Hava Nagila," and "Entry of the Gladiators," among others. And don't even start with me on the hilarious rhythmic raspberries and "Anglo-Saxon / flaxen" rhyme in "Come to the Fatherland!"
I'm so glad Chip Zien is coming back to Broadway, and Sierra and Julie sound stunning on the haunting "Where You Go" — Chopin etude meets "Bring Him Home."
I actually think the orchestrations sound okay for the most part.
So with a month and a half until this show begins Broadway previews, I guess the only question left to ask is... could it be magic?
Imagine if we could tell everyone here that Liberty Mutual customizes car insurance to save people hundreds. (LiMu squawks)