I saw Part 1 of the show last night, and (snow permitting...fingers crossed) I'll be seeing Part 2 tonight. I did see the show twice in London (Sept 2016 & Jan 2017), but all of my comparisons are against my memory/impressions of the show, so may not be exact.
I felt like the show still had all of the magic that I saw onstage in London -- and that all of the effects were much tighter. For these shows, I'm in the third row, and even close up the "magic" isn't very evident, with one exception that I don't mind because it's still very fun to watch. In London, the owls (after one preview of trying to use live owls...) were rendered by a lighting effect, but it seemed like a physical prop/puppet whizzing by yesterday, but I'll look much more closely tonight. The scene at the home for elderly wizards seems to have a *lot* more magic in it than I remember seeing in London and was a lot of fun! The audience was very engaged and most of the characters got entrance applause, and most displays of magic did, as well.
My one complaint last night was that sometimes the background or effect sound drowned out the dialogue for me -- I could barely hear Albus&Scorpius in a key scene on the train, and at times the background music seemed intrusive. There was one hold and reset in Act 2 because of what looked like a turntable issue.
The actors are in great form. Anthony Boyle as Scorpius is just a delight and a revelation, and I'm hoping NYC just falls in love with him, as well as Sam Clemmet as Albus. Scorpius really stayed with me after the first time I saw the show, and the second time I saw it in London, the actor had clearly really relaxed in to the role, maybe getting a touch broad at times, but what I saw last night was an extremely tight performance and I really hope a Tony nom is in his future. I adore Jamie Parker as Harry-- I think his performance really allows us to see the impact and lingering effects of his childhood trauma and years as (basically) a teenage soldier, as well as his love for his friends and family, and all his strengths and fallibilities. But it's also so much fun to watch the moments when he's playing a different character, for plot reasons. I find the brief moments of flashbacks to him as a child, pre-Hogwarts, to be so affecting.
Of the new cast, I was only struggling with Delphini-- and nothing to do with the actress' performance, really, but more that, in London, the character read to me as about 22, and last night she read to me as about 30. I think this may have to do with the makeup design on her and they might want to take a look at that. It changed how I felt about the character's interactions with Albus. Curious if anyone else felt the same?
The younger children I saw sitting nearby seemed a bit bored during stretches of the show; I think a little boy was falling asleep during a scene where some of the adult characters sit around a kitchen table and discuss their fears about failing their children as parents, about trying to protect them. It's really emotional content, especially when they talk about how their own childhoods shaped their parenting styles, but not so interesting to a kid.
I was disappointed that the theater lobby wasn't "transformed" after Part 1 the way it was in London, to reflect the events of the play. You do get a "keep the secrets" pin as you leave, but it's lightweight and plastic, not the metal badge like in London.
On the merch front, most of the merch looked the same as London -- there is a separate store for purchasing house merchandise like scarves, pens, bags, etc. The house redesigns for the show are really elegant, in my opinion! There is a t-shirt with the logo that also has "Lyric Theater-Broadway" on the back, and there is a special version of the companion book/illustrated program that's stamped "Broadway Preview Edition" on the front cover and will only be available until opening. The book is largely pictures/content from London, but does have some new content related to NY.
My seat was B-1. The stage is very high, but third row was a good view for me (and I got splashed in one scene). I'm not sure I would have wanted to be in first two rows.
I know this was long, but hope it was helpful! Happy to anwer any questions, and I'll report back on Part 2, assuming the snow allows me to see it!
Updated On: 3/21/18 at 11:41 AM