What the devil is that oddball Adam Guettel and Meryl duet from? It looks ridiculous, but intriguing. I wouldn't say Meryl's singing was particularly impressive in that clip, but, man, what a voice Adam Guettel has.
^^What I mean is that it's still tragic and heartbreaking for Rapunzel. She is stuck in a loveless, unhappy marriage while her mind has gone crazy. For the Witch, SURE it's sad for her to see her child die in front of her eyes, BUT it would mean that the Witch was right about her view of the world. In the film version it's tragic for the Witch as well because she was very WRONG about her warning to Rapunzel and she will never see her again.
I'm not saying it doesn't work. I'm just saying it's not as powerful. We also have to remember that neither Rapunzel or the Witch know that the Prince isn't faithful. Heck, is he even unfaithful in this version? Agony reprise got cut, right? That changes things a bit.
"and she will never see her again"
Well, technically, Rapunzel could always decide to forgive her mother and return to her. Not being mangled to bits sort of opens up her options...lol
I think deep down Rapunzel knew the Witch loved her. The Witch reminds me of Mama Rose. She wasn't a bad mother, just very very misguided. Like the Witch says, "I was just trying to be a good mother".
Actually I realized something else about this change that makes it "better" than the original...
I think it is far more interesting if the son that is second in line, and will likely never be king, is kind, sincere, gentle and faithful.
While the one who, let's face it, is probably king at the end of the show/movie...is charming, not sincere.
Sort of like Faramir being able to release the ring, when Boromir couldn't...having the "lesser" brother be the "better" person makes both characters more interesting.
Imagine "Agony" sung where one brother is only after the chase, while the other is truly in love.
" Like the Witch says, "I was just trying to be a good mother"."
I hope that in the movie...this line isn't as funny as when Bernadette did it. The line should be more emotional in my opinion. And yes, those clips of Meryl singing were/are wonderful. Those were from "The Music of Regret" in 2006.
I cannot wait to see the film...especially the Children Will Listen (looks beautiful in the script) and Last Midnight (the ending of that song looks epic in the script)
I don't like the tagline. Why didn't they use the actual line from "Children Will Listen"?
Careful the wish you make
It means the same thing but worded differently. The phrase "Be careful what you wish for" is too cliche, not to mention it ends in a preposition.
Salve, Regina, Mater misericordiae
Vita, dulcedo, et spes nostra
Salve, Salve Regina
Ad te clamamus exsules filii Eva
Ad te suspiramus, gementes et flentes
O clemens O pia
Salve, Regina, Mater misericordiae
Vita, dulcedo, et spes nostra
Salve, Salve Regina
Ad te clamamus exsules filii Eva
Ad te suspiramus, gementes et flentes
O clemens O pia
Perhaps because as lovely a lyric as it is, it isn't really a proper sentence? At least not in modern english.
I do agree that "Be Careful What You Wish For" is cliche though, and that they should have gone for something else. A lyric from the show would have been lovely, I just don't think it should have been that one.
I would have liked, "careful the tales you tell" or something along those lines. I like the poster, kind of annoyed it's just Streep but the artwork is beautiful.
Does anybody know why Johnny Depp's name is followed by his role in the movie? I'm curious. I thought that he was in the film, but all done up in CGI. I could be wrong though. Is he just voicing the role?
As for the tagline, it's cheesy and cliche, but it works for me and probably will for a majority of the audience. It was also probably favored over other quotes as it's an old and very familiar quote associated with fairytales. "Careful the wish you make" doesn't sound right out of the context of the song.
I'm glad the poster isn't the typical Disney live action poster (Oz, Maleficent, Alice in Wonderland). Those just end up looking cluttered. I'm sure there'll be another poster soon, however, with more characters on it. Disney usually pumps out several variations of the posters as the film's release date approaches. Updated On: 9/16/14 at 05:13 PM
I find the poster fascinating, personally. Disney has chosen artwork that doesn't really "go with" a PG rated film and has the potential to scare away kids and adults thinking of taking their kids. It almost has an 80's horror vibe to it, but absolutely nothing that says it's a musical and nothing saying they want younger audiences besides the "Disney" name.
"Does anybody know why Johnny Depp's name is followed by his role in the movie? I'm curious. I thought that he was in the film, but all done up in CGI. I could be wrong though. Is he just voicing the role? "
No. He is physically in the film with minor CG-flourishes.
I think it stands out, especially with how boring some of these posters tend to be. I couldn't agree more with StageManager2 and others re "careful the wish you make," that'd have been haunting and unique. Depp's role is mentioned because he is being featured almost as a special guest. It's a billing thing. It's fairly common when you have a big star who is billed "above the title" in the poster (especially over other people who'll have more scenes than him but aren't billed, like Tracey Ullman or Christine Baranski) and who has a relatively small role (in the case of Depp, I assume it's one or two scenes) to be billed with the added "as" and then the role they are playing.
"Some people can thrive and bloom living life in a living room, that's perfect for some people of one hundred and five. But I at least gotta try, when I think of all the sights that I gotta see, all the places I gotta play, all the things that I gotta be at"