Tag said: "The current Toronto production is very good. There are certainly many ‘wow’ moments and some stunning visuals. There were even mid-show ovations. I was reminded of the early days of Mamma Mia! when the audiences would just lose it when the first phrase of a song began. It’s very fun in that way.
Stark does read too young, but he makes it work. His part is drastically underwritten (why doesn’t he have a big solo moment? But maybe that’s intentional?)
Betsy is one of the best parts of this production. She lands the comedy. I think she’ll be a real contender for a supporting Tony next year.
Unfortunately, the rest of the casting is not as strong as the original West End company.
Lorna Courtney (Juliet) has a crazy amazing voice, and is generally wonderful in the part. But…there’s something off. Miriam-Teak Lee has such a strong presence and signature look, and that’s what’s missing here. Lorna just sort of blends in as ordinary. They’ve put her in the same costumes as Lee, which don’t fit her proportions as well, and they’ve neglected doing anything special with her hair/wig. I really missed the originality in her styling. She also just doesn’t have that star-quality that Lee has.
Ben Jackson Walker (Romeo) is completely bland and unremarkable onstage. You wonder why everyone, let alone Juliet, wants to be with him.
Poor Paulo…every one of his jokes landed with a thud. And when his rich baritone finally comes out late in Act 2, it’s so drastically different than the tone and sound of the rest of the show.
And perhaps the most miscast in the show is Philippe Arroyo as Francois. He’s fantastic but just totally the wrong type of performer for this role. He’s supposed to be the outsider, and dare I say he’s more suave and attractive than the guy playing Romeo.
The ensemble is working hard, and really bring a great energy to the show. Veronica Otim as Juliet’s mom is a real stand out, and is so delicious in that small part.
I imagine with the timeline there won’t be many changes (or changes in casting). But there’s potential for this show to be so much better.
Also random annoyance, during the curtain call they project character names during each bow. I wish they would put up performer names. It would make more sense."
These are my general concerns from the initial casting. Francois, Shakespeare, and Romeo should not come across as interchangeable.
I'm a huge fan of the show on the West End, including the replacement/understudies that I have seen. Their Canadian counterparts just seem underwhelming by comparison. Hope I am wrong though, I will certainly be seeing it!