I was at the first preview and didn't post anything then because I needed to think about my very mixed response to Micah Stock. On the one hand, it's a great performance in the sense that it's very lived-in and specific and believable, and in all of his interactions with Metcalf it worked. On the other hand, the other half of the story simply doesn't work with this performance...which makes it a bad performance? The first scene in the bar between him and his love interest was so awkward and off-putting to the degree that it never made any sense that it would continue beyond that night. If it had been a failed encounter to show how damaged he was and a means to drop the information about his aunt having cancer and we never saw the love interest again, then I would have bought it. (But of course he's needed later to spur the final confrontation between Metcalf-Stock.) But his dysfunction was so extreme and there was absolutely nothing I could hang on to why this person would want to continue seeing him. Someone above suggested the love interest is codependent, or maybe we're supposed to believe the options for gay men in this smallish town are so limited that he couldn't reject him so easily. But while we as an audience had seen enough of Ethan prior to this scene to know he wasn't a threat, watching it from the love interest's perspective (especially given how short he was and how so much taller Stock was), I was distinctly uncomfortable. If I hadn't seen the character before this, I would have thought, "You need to back away slowly. This person is going to murder you."
I'm all for body positivity and seeing a gay character who doesn't look like the norm, but he needed to be at least slightly less of a mess, or there needed to be something at all appealing about him to show why the Drea character continued seeing him. But there isn't, so while one half of the play is grounded and realistic, the other half is off in romance novel fantasyland, the kind, patient heroine sticking with the broody, damaged hero. Drea is doing great work in the kind of role that's typically underappreciated, since he has to convince there's any reason he could be drawn to this person, and comes far closer than he has any right to given what he's acting against. In the final scene between them, I know that I should consider it heartbreaking for Stock's character, but I was mostly watching Drea, and thinking, "Why are you still here? You need to leave him." And I was ultimately exasperated in how long it took to play out.
And once he was gone and we got back to the meat of the Metcalf-Stock plot the play righted itself again.
So yeah, I think half the play works and half doesn't.
Updated On: 10/30/25 at 11:13 AM