Posted: 5/21/25 at 7:38am
EW.
I know the Gaga on Broadway keeps coming up, but she definitely has some extra incentive now.
Updated On: 5/21/25 at 07:38 AM
Posted: 5/21/25 at 7:44am
I think we’re more likely to see her produce a Tony-hopeful production than star in one. I love LG, but I don’t see her collecting any more acting trophies, nor do I see her writing a full score to a musical.
Posted: 5/21/25 at 8:44am
RUkiddingme said: "Robert Lopez has 2."
Did I miss something! How does this relate to the post!
Posted: 5/21/25 at 8:46am
I didn’t know we counted Sports Emmys in EGOT, although I admit I don’t pay attention to Sports Emmys. Once upon a time, people didn’t want to count Whoopi as an EGOT winner because her Emmy was a Daytime Emmy.
Lady Gaga has an Emmy for music direction, and no one has won a Tony for music direction since 1964. They really need to change that.
Posted: 5/21/25 at 10:31am
Cynthia Erivo’s Emmy is for a musical performance on The Today Show and her Grammy Award was simply for being part of the cast on the cast recording of THE COLOR PURPLE, so there’s that.
Posted: 5/21/25 at 11:20am
BrodyFosse123 said: "Cynthia Erivo’s Emmy is for a musical performance on The Today Show and her Grammy Award was simply for being part of the cast on the cast recording of THE COLOR PURPLE, so there’s that."
Same goes for Ben Platt for Dear Evan Hansen (Emmy for a talk show performance, and Grammy for he album).
I also don't believe there shouldn't be a difference in those people who have an EGOT where one of the awards was given without competition...ie. Liza's Grammy is a Lifetime Achievement, or Streisand's Tony was for "Star of the Decade"
Posted: 5/21/25 at 11:22am
BrodyFosse123 said: "Cynthia Erivo’s Emmy is for a musical performance on The Today Show and her Grammy Award was simply for being part of the cast on the cast recording of THE COLOR PURPLE, so there’s that."
Your use of “simply” here is laughable. Erivo still has an Emmy and a Grammy, regardless of this blatant attempt to undermine it.
Whoopi’s Tony in her EGOT is for producing. That doesn’t make her any less of an EGOT winner. There’s no ruling that states you can only be a “true” EGOT if all four awards are for performance in a specific capacity.
Posted: 5/21/25 at 12:25pm
ColorTheHours048 said: "I think we’re more likely to see her produce a Tony-hopeful production than star in one."
This is the last thing she'll do. She recently said in an interview that'd she love to write an original musical. I can absolutely see her taking the Cyndi Lauper/Kinky Boots route easily, writing all new music.
No way will she pay for her EGOT like JHUD.
Posted: 5/21/25 at 1:38pm
A Sports Emmy?
Posted: 5/21/25 at 2:14pm
everythingtaboo said: "A Sports Emmy?"
For her Super Bowl Half-Time show performance.
Posted: 5/21/25 at 2:26pm
BrodyFosse123 said: "Cynthia Erivo’s Emmy is for a musical performance on The Today Show and her Grammy Award was simply for being part of the cast on the cast recording of THE COLOR PURPLE, so there’s that."
She has nothing to do with this post and you've just described hundreds of people that won for a performance on television and also the Grammy. Weird you'd single her out.
Posted: 5/21/25 at 3:47pm
Brody saying something ignorant and idiotic? I’m shocked…
Posted: 5/21/25 at 5:34pm
Idinamenzel18 said: "ColorTheHours048 said: "I think we’re more likely to see her produce a Tony-hopeful production than star in one."
This is the last thing she'll do. She recently said in an interview that'd she love to write anoriginal musical. I can absolutely see her taking the Cyndi Lauper/Kinky Boots route easily, writing all new music.
No way will she pay for her EGOT like JHUD."
Unsure why you’re singling out Jennifer Hudson for having a Tony for producing when there are others who’ve done the same.
And I’m aware of what Gaga said she wanted, but what I’m saying is I think we’re more likely to see her earning that Tony with a producing credit. It’s not shameful to earn it that way, and I doubt it’s “the last thing she’ll do.”
Posted: 5/21/25 at 5:39pm
Unsure why you’re singling out Jennifer Hudson for having a Tony for producing when there are others who’ve done the same.
And I’m aware of what Gaga said she wanted, but what I’m saying is I think we’re more likely to see her earning that Tony with a producing credit. It’s not shameful to earn it that way, and I doubt it’s “the last thing she’ll do.”"
Never said it was shameful, but let's be real, anyone with money can tack their name onto a producing credit and win a Tony if they want to. It just isn't the same.
If you know anything about the way Gaga works, she's not going to pay her way to EGOT status.
You also claimed you can't see her writing a whole score? But lesser known artists (Sara Bareilles, Ingrid Michaelson) have taken that onto their plate. She's more than capable of doing so, and clearly wants to.
Posted: 5/21/25 at 5:39pm
TotallyEffed said: "Brody saying something ignorant and idiotic? I’m shocked…"
You lobbing another personal insult and America’s Sweetheart being condescending? Double shocker!
Posted: 5/21/25 at 5:42pm
Unsure why you’re singling out Jennifer Hudson for having a Tony for producing when there are others who’ve done the same.
And for the record, I singled out Jennifer because she's certainly talented enough to win a Tony without producing. As is Gaga. Getting one from producing isn't shameful, but it's certainly a cop out.
Posted: 5/21/25 at 5:45pm
BrodyFosse123 said: "everythingtaboo said: "A Sports Emmy?"
For her Super Bowl Half-Time show performance."
It was for her performance during the Super Bowl pregame show.
I think the most likely scenario she wins a Tony Award would be for producing or writing a show. However, I would love to see her in a golden age musical revival directed by Jamie Lloyd. Let’s say… The Sound of Music?
Updated On: 5/21/25 at 05:45 PM
Posted: 5/21/25 at 6:28pm
I think the most likely scenario she wins a Tony Award would be for producing or writing a show. However, I would love to see her in a golden age musical revival directed by Jamie Lloyd. Let’s say… The Sound of Music?
Posted: 5/21/25 at 11:03pm
BrodyFosse123 said: "I think the most likely scenario she wins a Tony Award would be for producing or writing a show. However, I would love to see her in a golden age musical revival directed by Jamie Lloyd. Let’s say… The Sound of Music?
Wow! I’ve never seen this before. What is it from?
"
Posted: 5/21/25 at 11:15pm
The 2015 Academy Awards/Oscars - in celebration of THE SOUND OF MUSIC’s 50th anniversary. 
Posted: 5/22/25 at 12:11am
I think it’s far more likely that writes an original score. I could also see her doing something like Springsteen and the committee giving her a trophy.
Posted: 5/22/25 at 12:17am
Well color me dumb, I had no idea that the Grammys came in some many different categories.
