My thoughts on tonight’s show:
THE GOOD:
- Rob McClure, Rob McClure, Rob McClure!! There’s a reason he continues to star in musical comedy and that’s because he’s the one of the true blue remaining musical comedy stars left that have crossed over to TV or film. He is a workhorse, an imp, and an all-around delight. If they gave Santino Fontana a Tony for whatever “Tootsie” was, Rob deserves 2.
- The newer jokes definitely have a bit more bite to them than the movie. Some of them, I audibly reacted because, especially the insults, were some sick burns. My personal favorite joke though was “Oh, the kids have seen me dance. It looks like two hippos fighting under a duvet!”…I died.
- The female children are a big highlight. Annalise Scarpaci has one HELL of a voice and I found her Lydia to have quite a few more layers than her film counterpart. The few times she could’ve fallen into that “angsty teen” trope, she didn’t. Avery Sell was just adorable and innocent and my heart broke every time she blamed herself for her parents split.
- Though it took her a while to get there, Jenn Gambatese was believable as a mother completely unraveled and healed by the end.
THE BAD:
- One too many characters are drawn a bit one-dimensionally. The son, Stu, and Mr. Jolly just seemed to exist in the background instead of any purposeful driving in the plot.
- Conversely some of the characters are drawn WAY too broadly on the brink of caricature. Mrs. Sellner went from a very droll and dry comedic role to one full of unnecessary sass and the humor in her interactions was lost. (Though Charity Dawson can really belt her lovely lady lumps off.) Oscar seems wasted in his role and Ghee is somehow doing a cross of Billy Porter and Hollywood Montrose. Also, what was the deal with Janet Lundy? That character just made no sense in terms of personality.
- The whole show takes about 15-20 minutes to take off and, while the plot is engaging and we all know how it goes, the songs that should buoy the show are very pedestrian and generic - almost as if they were dashed off the day before previews and shoehorned in.
THE TRIVIAL:
- Jerry Zaks was in the audience across the aisle from me tonight and I was gawking a couple times because, c’mon, the man is LEGENDARY. (I was too afraid to say hi).
- HOW DARE YOU CAST CASEY GARVIN, PUT HIM IN A GYM SCENE, AND LEAVE HIM IN A TRACKSUIT THE WHOLE TIME. THROW AWAY THE THE WHOLE SHOW BASED ON THIS ALONE!!! (Sarcasm font)
Overall, it gets a B- from me. Definitely could be better in a few aspects, but I admittedly laughed quite a bit and found the show to be a lot like comfort food, which is apropos the day before thanksgiving
Check out my eBay page for sales on Playbills!!
www.ebay.com/usr/missvirginiahamm