Broadway Legend Joined: 3/29/05
St. Elmo's fire! Laughing so hard, I just sprayed coffee all over my computer screen. That comparison is spot on.
My $.02:
-Dug the trailer, still very excited for the movie.
-Idina's line delivery (which seems to be a hot topic of discussion) - meh. I don't think that line's getting her any Oscar noms. But damn, the girl looks good.
-The re-recording/mixing of Finale B - sounds so different from the OCR. I like it though. Kind of threw me for a loop at first, but I liked it. I'll have to get the soundtrack.
-The movie voiceover man always makes me chuckle. I think he is the same voiceover man in 90% of movie trailers.
Just one thing I want to add, personally looved the trailer, watched it twice, tear ran down during Idina's line.
But those who are criticizing both Idina's and Adam's delivery I personally think should wait till you see the scene in context. Maybe you'll see it fits in perfectly with the rest of the scene and the mood and whatever. I just think...we should try to hold criticisms till the movie actually comes out, though personally from what I've seen...I wouldn't say the movie is going to be perfect, but I think I will love it enough to overlook and perhaps not even acknowledge the faults--Evelyn, I think that's what's going on now, and what may happen when the movie comes out. If it's a great movie, I personally am not gonna care to dwell on the faults. Then again I'm one of the few who love the Phantom movie, and I know there are faults there, don't dwell on those either...so maybe I'm a bad example, because I do think the Rent movie will if nothing else be more critically and commercially appreciated than Phantom.
"But those who are criticizing both Idina's and Adam's delivery I personally think should wait till you see the scene in context. Maybe you'll see it fits in perfectly with the rest of the scene and the mood and whatever."
I think you're right, it may fight perfectly in context, but if it doesn't, and Columbus and Co. know that it doesn't, I hope that they fix it.
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/29/05
I wasn't scrutinizing - just making an observation in response to some of the previous posts within the thread. Personally, I'm going to wait for the movie to make my final opinions.
My comments were specific to the trailer, and the trailer alone! : )
I agree about Adam and Idina's line. I realize me criticizing it at this point is kind of silly.
However, my statement on Adam's acting had nothing to do with what I saw in the trailer.
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/22/05
yea,i agree w/ the not judging anything until you see the context.kinda pointlesss(even tho i did it)
Alright, I only read a couple of other posts, so I'll just throw my thoughts in.
I don't see anything wrong with Adam's line delivery, if you listen to it, it's just good diction. Nothing with delivery. Also, with Idina's delivery, I agree with those posts that said she was remembering him. If you watch her expression, you can tell she's thinking about him. That's why it works.
The whole couch sequence might have just been filmed for the trailer. I know a lot of movies film extra footage to use in the trailer, so maybe that's what it's for.
Also, with the whole 'spoiling the ending' thing, even in the other trailers, they know someone dies. They just don't know who. Same with this trailer. You know someone dies, but you're left on a ledge to find out who it is if you haven't seen the show.
I really like this trailer, it's different. I like the use of Finale B, because I find it to have such a strong message, just like Seasons of Love.
So yeah .. that's my two cents.
Adam's delivery sounded ok to me.
I love it!!!! It rocked my socks!
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/14/04
If anything, the trailer leads you to believe a GIRL has died, because Idina says "It was you, baby"...and she never says "he" or "she".
This is entirely off topic but I just have to ask: BroadwayGirl107 where did u get that Idina quote that you use as your signature?
Thanks and sorry for the interruption, lol
Broadway Star Joined: 11/28/04
The trailer didnt make me cry like the last one, but i think that was because it was the first ever showing of any of it....so that makes sense...
the film still looks perfect to me :)
Xxx
Featured Actor Joined: 1/9/05
I just showed my twin brother the new trailer, and he said that it looked like "a very serious episode of Friends." He said that it doesn't look bad, but it's just not something that he would see.
And his only other comment was, "Is that Rosario Dawson? She looks hot."
Rosario = UBER HOT!!!!!
I finally saw the new trailer (I have not been able to get online for a while)......oh my God. I actually teared up during the Idina line. It looks so gorgeous and I predict a high box office take in with lots and lots of new RENT fans added to the bunch of thousands already out there blasting RENT OBC in the car. Can't Wait!!!!
What a wonderful present I find after returning from vacation! I honestly think it LOOKS and SOUNDS absolutely.... BREATHTAKING!
-The cinematography is simply stunning! Mad props to Stephen Goldblatt, who also (I just found out) did Angels in America! Snaps for the cinematography.
-Hearing yet another song fully mixed, I am totally at ease about the poor sound clips on the main site. This film WILL sound great!
-I was not bothered at all by anyone's line delivery at all in the trailer, although, I really liked Anthony's line at the beginning! Idina, to me, just looks and sounds like she is fondly remembering a friend who passed. I've seen the same kind of speech given at a real funeral... sad but controlling their emotions on the outside. Angel wouldn't have wanted a sad funeral anyways.
-The staging for Finale B IS slightly awkward in the TRAILER! I am totally confident that it will NOT appear in the film that way.
**LISTEN TO THE OTHERS WHO SAY THAT FILMMAKERS PURPOSELY SHOOT EXTRA FOOTAGE FOR TRAILERS. IT'S TRUE. OR ELSE THEY STAGED AND FILMED IT DIFFERENT WAYS AND WILL CHOOSE THE ONE THAT WORKS BEST FOR THE FILM.** Put your minds at ease about that.
BTW: I'm assuming the shot of Mimi on the fire escape is OUT TONIGHT... so where are the blue Mimi pants? I've heard they made it into the movie... but where are they? lol
OH... and ROSARIO is gonna ROCK THE HOUSE as Mimi!
She looks HOT HOT HOT!!!
em-lee: yeah, my brother said the SAME thing - the Friends rference! 'course, he said "it looks like Ross and rachel are homeless and on crack". i thought that was hilarious. but he did say he would see it if rosario was indeed a stripper.
whatever gets them in the movie, you know? :)
i loved when jesse spun around on the subway. i have a feeling his performance will be one of my favorites. he's so sweet and charming.
hey i was wondering is there a link where you can see the international trailer?
Featured Actor Joined: 1/9/05
kas- That cracked me up! Well, boys will be boys. Maybe my brother will see it too if I tell him that Rosario plays a stripper. Yeah, that would probably work.
I mentioned this over on the CB boards, but I think that the shot of the cast on the couch during Finale B just may be a type of "base shot" (sorry, I'm not familiar with film terminology) that the movie comes back to after cutting away to other shots of the cast, like Mark setting up his movie, everyone watching his movie, ect. Like One Song Glory where during the song we'll see Adam sing and also see flashbacks of his life with April. I think the same thing will happen with Finale B, only we'll see "flashforwards."
I hope that makes sense.
it makes sense to me. it may very well be the base shot, or the foundation shot that the whole scene is built around. scenes in motion pictures are shot several different ways and from many different angles. the shots used in the trailer may or maynot make the final cut, it's all in the editing and that is what i was trying to get at when i originally told everyone not to base the movie on this trailer to begin with but then a certain poster chose to "jump down my throat" anyway.
Updated On: 8/27/05 at 02:35 PM
Swing Joined: 11/26/04
During Finale B, I thought they were all on the bed in the apartment were Mimi dies and comes back? Its not a couch...
Videos