Official "Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera" Reviews Thread — Page 4

1) I have noticed that most of the reviewers that gave it horrible reviews, hated the show in the first place...it seems that some of them are getting thier revenge for the show prospering so well.

2) How can it recieve all of these bad reviews and get all of these nominations, it was even nominated for the critic's choice awards, so someone must like it, because people are voting for it!

I cannot wait to see this movie!

We intend to see it Christmas day.

I am trying to figure out how the film ends with the chandelier as opposed to where it happens in the show

Crawford was to old to play it now. He was so overweight in DOTV he could have played the chandelier in the movie

---

Just in from seeing so here goes:

Overall it is a great movie. It may drag here and there a little but, for the most part, it stays intact. The lip synching is a little off but, not being a huge ALW fan, I enjoyed myself.

If you see this movie for any reason, see it for Emmy Rossum. She absolutely wowed me! She is gorgeous throughout this entire film and her voice, although pre recorded, was amazing. She sings like an angel. Her performance is absolutely superb and this will me the movie that's going to put her on the map. (I still can't believe that Katie Holmes was supposed to play this part.)

Gerard Butler's voice may get a little rough here and there, but his acting is filled to the brim with PASSION. He lives and breathes the character and can hold a tune pretty well. I can tell that the director was going for a very sexy and rough Phantom, and he achieves it without compromising the validity of the work. It was an excellent casting choice.

Patrick Wilson is Patrick Wilson. His voice is as sweet as honey and he truly does Raoul justice. In fact, I could not see Alan Cumming playing this part. There's really nothing more to say about him. He does an excellent part and you can tell he has the most stage experience. He feels right at home in this movie and does a great job in the part.

Sadly, I was dissapointed in Minnie Driver. I really wanted to see her do well. But, I found myself searching for a reason to like her in this movie. Her Italian accent was awful unfortunately and it's so obvious that it's not her voice singing. She does, however play the part off decently. She has a very pompous air to her and she really embodies Carlotta in her body language...but not much else.

The set is amazing...truly amazing. And so are the effects. The music is wonderful. Some of the dancing seemes a bit too choreographed. The "Masquerade" scene, I feel, should have been done a little differently. It seems it was directed to be for the audience. I don't know how to put it into words...it just seems that, at that moment, they knew that they were performing in a movie rather than being at a party. If that makes any sense at all. The costumes are absolutely gorgeous.

I am not the best reviewer in the world but I tried to give my honest opinion without sounding biased. Overall it is a very enjoyable night at the movies. Just make sure you go to the bathroom before you take your seat...I didn't...nuff said.

---

I liked it a lot. It's quite thrilling. Gerard is so frikin' sexy as the phantom. Emmy is charming and Patrick is just adorable. I loved the long hair I think it looks great on him. I was surprised how intact it actually came. About 90% of the stage version is preserved on film. It's only when Mdm. Giry begins talking about the traveling circus and that whole flashback scene that the film starts to vier off in a different direction than on stage, but over all I was very impressed. I loved how they continued the flashbacks to the auction all through out the film. On stage we see the auction and then that's it. Never again. On film we're able to see the whole story through the eyes of the older Raoul and Mdm. Giry who in reality should be dead by 1919 but whatever...

Umm... the nudity was pretty funny. A stage hand moons Carlotta during "Prima Donna". That was hilarious.

Patrick in a ripped shirt on a white horse was awesome and Gerry's sexy chest hair cut between his ripped shirt for the final lair scene was all just soooooooooooo sexyful.

I was very pleased. I think they did a great job.

I think, however, had they placed the "We Have All Been Blind"/"Twisted Every Way" song where it is supposed to be: AFTER "Why So Silent?" the last part of the film would not have dragged so much as everyone is saying...

Updated On: 12/22/04 at 08:22 PM

Gerard Buttler is very, very SEXY. they tried, obviously to make him look ugly, but even with part of his face boily and his hair thinning on the one side, I'd still let him rape me...

Well, the critics are wrong.

Wound up going tonight because I had nothing better to do. I wasn't a fan of the show or the score. Tonight, I fell in love with it. This is by far one of the most beautiful films I have ever seen. The costumes, the scenery, the performances, the score are all brilliant and beautiful.

See Gerard Butler for yourself. He sent shivers down my spine (the good kind).

Just... go. Take your OWN opinion, not a critic's or anyone's on here.

---

well, Patrick goes without saying. we've all seen him naked, but I was surprised by Gerard. I've never been that glued to someone in a movie before... his shirt for the final scene was just awesome. I kept thinking, "you're in the water! take it off!!!"

Yes...he certainly has a knack for playing great literary characters...Dracula, The Phantom, and now I see he's playing Beowulf in a film adaptation of the classic story. Perhaps that will be the one where the shirt comes off????

---

"keep your hand at the level of your eyes" is in reference to the lasso that the phantom uses a lot to kill people. Joseph and Giry demonstrate in the film when she put the lasso around his neck and he was able to put his hand up in time to keep from being choked... hope that helps.

Just my two cents ... I enjoyed it, however I think overall it won't be recieved well by the general public. I think broadway fans will get it, but this isn't going to be the next hit like Chicago. I'm afraid a lot of non-theatre people are going to go see it b/c they liked Chicago and be bored out of their minds. It seems to me like perhaps we're taking a step back. It was visually stunning, Minnie was fabulous, Patrick is hot but I'm afraid overall people just aren't going to be entertained. I just saw it at the Zeigfeld theatre. I also saw Moulin Rouge and Chicago there on opening day. Moulin Rouge and Chicago were both sold out to adoring crowds and recieved applause after the musical numbers. This audience was maybe 1/2 full, and pretty dead. I think this is just they way its going to be. Sad really. Hopefully "The Producers" will bring back some musical fans!

I just got back from the movie, and he's my small "review:"

I thought the entire thing was amazing, and much more effective and heartbreaking than on stage. I really really loved every second of it, and my only complaint would be the lipsinking. This movie is spectacular, and I had chills through most of it. No, their voices weren't as strong as those I've seen do it on Broadway and as a soundtrack, I would much rather listen to the OLC than the movie but their voices worked very well in the movie and I didn't find them weak at all. Some people have said that there's no emotion in the acting of Christine and the Phantom, but I found them both amazing and they kept me interested and actually caring about their characters the entire time. I've never seen the Phantom so attractive and sexy before, and until this movie I never really accepted the phantom as a "normal" human being and could never understand why Christine would be so drawn to him. Gerard is gorgeous! Maybe I loved it more than most people I've talked to because I went in expecting it to be wretched. Seeing this movie really reminded me of why I first fell in love with this show years ago. Maybe it's only me, but this movie is the only time I actually cared about Christine's emotions, and the first time the Phantom actually broke my heart I thought it was a truly beautiful film. The ending was great - I loved the black and white segments. I'm definitely going back!

---

I really don't think the Phantom being that hot is a bad thing at all - you can't be TOO goodlooking. It makes you feel worse for him and actually want him to get Christine. If the Phantom in this movie had been nasty looking, I wouldn't be interested in his character.

---