I don’t mean that I think they should exclude just because you’ll remember it, but that it will completely and totally overwhelm the rest of the score, even if it were first rate. Our minds are just naturally drawn to the familiar and the rest of the score would never be able to live up to it.
Did you not think Rocky’s score was overwhelmed by Eye of the Tiger or Ghost’s score was overwhelmed by Unchained Melody?
Even with the best score, if you swapped out Losing My Mind for I Will Always Love You, a person walking out of Follies would have an uphill battle retaining anything other than the pop hit.
Maybe I’m in the minority about not wanting this hits in otherwise original scores, but I think it creates a standard that the new composers can’t live up to and basically says to them, why not just create a jukebox score for this show instead?
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!