This thread is a treasure trove of bizarre comments.
either she is a genius (which I am not denying) or well she is the only director willing to try and completly reinterpret "semi" classics No, she reinterpreted one that transferred to Broadway and one that may transfer to Broadway, but she's the only director reinterpreting revivals. Just her. All by her lonesome. Nobody has thought of it before or since.
So I fail to see how it can flop?? If people don't want to see it and don't buy tickets, it will flop. A big hit in the 70s doesn't translate to a big hit revival. Remember the 1997 Annie or both revivals of Company?
If Drood is staying afloat I'm sure Pippin will do just fine. Oh, absolutely. The correlation between the two shows is unmistakable.
I mean, it's slightly well known, but I'm from the South and never seen anyone put on a production of it. I'm from "the South" and I've seen it produced several times. What about this show do you believe is so specifically off-putting to anyone who lives below the Mason-Dixon line? Does the script only make references to the Midwest or New England? Or perhaps it's the veiled references to abolishing slavery that keeps this musical out of the South.
Yes, they are recognizable Broadway names in the cast, but not anyone that somebody from Kansas or Illinois or where is necessarily gonna have heard of. OMG YES! Those wackos in Illinois are terribly unfamiliar with the BROAD WAY. That's why they fail to try out new Broadway musicals in Illinois pretty much EVERY SINGLE YEAR. Because living outside of New York means you have no access to anything Broadway related. Why, even now, right this very moment, I'm not reading this thread or typing this post because I couldn't possibly know anything about it! THIS ISN'T HAPPENING!
I do think it's interesting that following the successes of Avenue Q, In the Heights, Spring Awakening, Urinetown, Memphis and God knows what else, people still believe that it takes NAMES to sell a show. Names can help if a star has a built-in audience like Ricky Martin. In many cases, shows with names can go down in flames as MASSIVE failures a la On a Clear Day. The speculation as to the success of this production from those who haven't seen it truly baffles me. If you guys have such reliable crystal balls, why aren't you picking lottery numbers?
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian