egghumor---okay, now it's my turn to say, "wow" and be hugely impressed.
I loved "Smile" when I saw it in previews, and I thought the book, music, and lyrics were great. Very unusual!
I remember opening the Playbill before it started and checking out the song list. There were several "chunks" (for lack of a more delicate word) of songs/scenes/transitions strung together, very much like the "Hello, Twelve" Montage in A Chorus Line, as far as structure goes. Not too many stand-alone songs. I knew, even before the overture, that it was going to be a special show, and I wasn't disappointed. I loved the way it all flowed together (dialogue into song into dance into scene change, etc.).
I'm sorry if Marvin was frustrated with the collaboration, and I do see that when your partner is the lyricist AND the book writer AND the director ... you're "outnumbered." But I think they did a terrific job.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22