Voter said: "Oh yes, it's totally wrong to say that it doesn't make sense for Maria Von Trappto be a POC. Even totally ignoring that she was a real person who was white, the story is about the rise of Nazis in 1938 Austria, a time and place whereblack peoplewere severely ostracized and excluded fromsociety. The characters benefit from social acceptance due to their white privilege. Some shows race is incidental to the plot, I'm all for diverging from original castings, but color conscious casting and color blind casting are different and it makes no sense here."
Let's just go back to the rumors of Rachel Zelger starring, then - she's Polish!
Seriously, though... it's a musical, and story-wise its barely accurate to the true story already. For that matter, we just had Audra McDonald in Gypsy (and Audra herself played Mother Superior in the live SOM broadcast).
And if you really want to dig into the sociological implications - Captain Von Trapp had privilege. Maria did not. Maria very pointedly has nothing but her vibrant spirit. It's also a major plot point that she doesn't fit in at the convent and at the Trapp family estate she's not well liked by the Captain's Nazi-adjacent fiancé. Casting a Black woman in the role could add additional layers to the character, should they choose to direct it that way. Even if they don't, Jasmine Amy Rogers has the talent, voice, and personality to make a wonderful Maria all on her own.
It'll be fine.