steven22 said: "I saw the show last night and I’m not sure if it was because I went in with low expectations, or Idina can do no wrong in my eyes, but I enjoyed the show. Was it perfect? Absolutely not. But it was enjoyable and Idina is giving a great performance (shoutout to Khalia Wilcoxin, what a voice!)."
Agree wholeheartedly with everything in this review. Went in with low expectations for the show other than that I would gladly watch Idina sing the phone book, so just seeing her do her thing would be enough for me. We actually enjoyed it. It’s an Idina belting vehicle, so diehard fans like me will be pleased enough with that. Beyond that, there are some pretty cool production aspects happening with the tree climbing, and her song where she sings completely in the air (and upside down at one point) was impressive. Khaila Wilcoxon is phenomenal, it’s too bad her part isn’t meatier but I expect we’ll be seeing more of her. As this other reviewer said, it’s far from perfect and there’s at least 10 min I think they could have easily cut. Some aspects work better than others. But I will always give kudos to people trying to do an original musical when so many these days are jukebox, biopic, or adapted from movies. Beyond that, its themes of grief can hit the viewer differently depending on their own experiences, and having gone through a great loss recently of someone close to us, we were suckers for the ending and found myself tearing up. I could imagine if you weren’t ripe for those themes to hit then it could come off somewhat cliche. All in all, I enjoyed it much more than I thought I would and I’d encourage avid Broadway goers to at least see it. I’ve definitely seen worse, both this season and last. At the very least it’s something different, and a chance to see Idina is always great in my book.