Posted: 3/8/25 at 5:28pm
After SpongeBob SquarePants, Redwood is the second Tina Landau directed musical I was kind of shocked how much I liked it. The immersive spectacle aspect of the show, isn't an obvious fit given the subject matter of grief, but was genuinely impressive. I also think it's commendable Menzel focused on a project so physically demanding and commercially risky when doing a revival would probably be easier money.
Some additional thoughts:
#1. When it comes to Broadway songs about people in trees, Sondheim did more for the genre in 7 minutes than Redwood does devoting nearly 2 hours to the topic. There are way too many songs in the Defying Gravity/Let It Go belting power ballad mode, and while it's what Menzel is best known for, it gets very musically repetitive. I often think the songs featuring Michael Park and Khaila Wilcoxon sounded better, in part because they broke up the monotony.
#2. With a lot of great singers, they make singing look effortless. With Menzel, and I've seen her live a couple of times, it's often impressive but she makes hitting the right note seem like a lot of work. This role would be a huge challenge to do 8 times a week even if there wasn't any singing.
#3. Between the main cast and standbys, 4 of the actors appeared in Dear Evan Hansen, another show largely about coping with grief.