#1
Posted: 11/26/06 at 12:57am
I just came back from seeing the show this evening (11/25)... this was my 7th time since 1990, and I have to say that Daphne's performance as Fantine is so misscast (sp?), that it had people actually cringing in their seats and shaking their heads when she sang. No further exaggeration... during intermission, the SOLE topic of conversation heard wherever you turned was how bad she is in this role.
I have not seen her in other works, I don't doubt that she is talented, but oh so wrong for this part. Someone else brought up in another thread that we have to remember she was a "dying whore." While this is true, she was always a character with a tender and gentle heart. This was sort of what separated her from the common street prostitute.
To hear her songs in such a harsh, raspy voice was a shock, and her emotions/gestures/posture did not fit the chaacter either. It sounded like Seymour's girlfriend from the Little Shop of Horrors movie was singing, and it was awful.
I had to laugh while I was waiting in the line for the men's room at intermission when someone commented how grateful they were that she died 20 minutes into the show.
I have not seen her in other works, I don't doubt that she is talented, but oh so wrong for this part. Someone else brought up in another thread that we have to remember she was a "dying whore." While this is true, she was always a character with a tender and gentle heart. This was sort of what separated her from the common street prostitute.
To hear her songs in such a harsh, raspy voice was a shock, and her emotions/gestures/posture did not fit the chaacter either. It sounded like Seymour's girlfriend from the Little Shop of Horrors movie was singing, and it was awful.
I had to laugh while I was waiting in the line for the men's room at intermission when someone commented how grateful they were that she died 20 minutes into the show.
Updated On: 11/27/06 at 12:57 AM