Rumor: ALL OUT Heading to The Nederlander

[BoringBoredBoard40]

Posted: 8/11/25 at 12:44am

"All Out: Comedy About Life", the sequel show to "All In: Comedy About Love" is supposedly taking the Nederlander for the holiday season, expect a mid November to late January run before a musical moves into the theater in the spring. Same idea, four performers, rotating cast with two big names leading for five weeks each. 

[Crusty Bagel]

Posted: 8/11/25 at 5:56am

What’s the musical coming in the spring ?

[rosscoe(au)]

Posted: 8/11/25 at 7:06am

Wasn’t the first one a flop? Which ask the question if so, why try again with anew show! 

[GiantsInTheSky2]

Posted: 8/11/25 at 7:18am

rosscoe(au) said: "Wasn’t the first one a flop? Which ask the question if so, why try again with anew show!"

Lol, no it wasn’t. People weren’t happy with the ticket price to watch people read out loud from a script, but it recouped capitalization prior to closing. The show’s success is what led to them announcing and producing this companion piece. 

[rosscoe(au)]

Posted: 8/11/25 at 12:24pm

Thank you. I thought it flopped for some reason .Appreciate the correction. 

[Jordan Catalano]

Posted: 8/11/25 at 6:20pm

Financially it was a success. I know a lot of people (myself included) got tickets obviously thinking it was a play so when we found out it was people on chairs reading from a book, they already had our money. Most people I know really disliked it and I can’t imagine would go back for round two. Now that everyone knows what it’ll be, I do wonder if they’ll have slower sales. 

[EDSOSLO858]

Posted: 8/11/25 at 6:37pm

Yep, should be another big hit. 

[BoringBoredBoard40]

Posted: 10/15/25 at 7:19pm

Tickets and cast announcement tomorrow at 10am.est per an email blast that just went out

[Intotheblue]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 3:57am

Schmigadoon

[EDSOSLO858]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 9:59am

Performances begin December 12, and it will run through March 8. 

The rotating cast of four will feature the following:

• Jim Gaffigan
• Eric Andre
• Abbi Jacobson
• Jon Stewart
• Wayne Brady
• Ben Schwartz
• Cecily Strong
• Mike Birbiglia
• Sarah Silverman
• Heidi Gardner
• Jason Mantzoukas
• Craig Robinson
• Ray Romano
• Nicholas Braun
• Ashley Park

...plus one more guest TBA later.

Original music will be provided this time around by Lawrence (Gracie and Clyde Lawrence's soul-pop group).

For exact dates for each star, visit alloutbroadway.com

 

Updated On: 10/16/25 at 09:59 AM

[Kad]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 10:28am

They're all performers I like but there's really nobody there that would make me want to buy a ticket- particularly after having sat through All In. I hope the women have less thankless, stereotypical roles this time around, though. 

[RippedMan]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 10:39am

I simple don’t understand the point of any of this. 

[Ensemble1698878795]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 10:44am

RippedMan said: "I simple don’t understand the point of any of this."

Oh it’s quite clear: it’s a money grab. They don’t care if it’s good or moving. They know a bunch of people will pay top dollar to come see their favorite celeb read the phone book. It’s not art, it’s pure capitalism in a theater. 

[RippedMan]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 11:14am

Yeah, I guess that's why I just don't...care? It just feels super lazy across the board. 

[always bway]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 11:23am

Hmmm I guess it really is a light year for new shows. 

[GiantsInTheSky2]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 11:24am

RippedMan said: "Yeah, I guess that's why I just don't...care? It just feels super lazy across the board."

Agreed, especially since this is supposed to be a Broadway debut for multiple people across both shows.

Would be more exciting if…it wasn’t this? I like the idea of a rotating cast, but these aren’t amateurs. These folks are perfectly capable of an actual performance. 

[barcelona20]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 11:25am

Lawrence will be the best part by far.

[Alex Kulak2]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 12:53pm

barcelona20 said: "Lawrence will be the best part by far."

If they switch the marketing to "Lawrence on Broadway, featuring some nonsense in between the songs", I might get on board.

[tacotheatrelover]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 2:15pm

I like the fact Sonic the Hedgehog is in this, that's cool. Other than that I really couldn't care about it.

[quizking101]

Posted: 10/16/25 at 2:56pm

I bought a ticket for one of the Jon Stewart days since I’m a fan of his and would like to see him live outside of a Daily Show setting but the rotating cast for this show has big “direct-to-video sequel” energy.

I’m surprised Nicholas Braun was booked considering there is an issue (that I cannot speak of on this board) he has t8 deal with come January after GPI ends downtown. Him getting booked is an assumption that he may actually be available.

[EDSOSLO858]

Posted: 12/2/25 at 2:11pm

Ike Barinholtz and Jenny Slate complete the onstage rotating cast.

Kevin Del Aguila and Olivia Puckett have also joined as understudies.

[quizking101]

Posted: 12/2/25 at 2:23pm

Barinholtz bumped Gaffigan to later in the run, which I’m more than fine with. 

Slate jumps in for the the last 3 weeks of the run with Ray Romano, Nicholas Braun, and Ashley Park.

Beck Bennett fills the last mid-January slot with Wayne Brady, Cecily Strong, and Heidi Gardner

 

[Sutton Ross]

Posted: 12/2/25 at 2:28pm

You honestly think Nicholas Bruan with his little UI misdemeanor charge and a violation for operating his car without lights on will land him in jail? Lolz. He's a rich white man, he will pay a fine and go on with his boozy life, which apparently means a lot of theater.

[DramaTeach]

Posted: 12/2/25 at 2:40pm

This is such a lackluster cast, IMO. At least the other one had some names that made me consider getting a ticket. Good luck to them.

[two ladies tickets]

Posted: 12/2/25 at 5:15pm

Just for clarification: the charges against Braun were dropped at the beginning of November.