lastmidnights said: "…
I didn't think it was possible, but I slightly preferred Jordan Donica's Max. I went back specifically to see him, but wasn't expecting him to be such a standout. Thaxton's Max was perfection, but Donica is just as good, if not better. …”
I was blown away by Donica’s voice. However, I thought he looked too young (couldn’t they have added a few white streaks to his hair?). Also, in my opinion, Thaxton is the superior actor. In Act 2, Thaxton’s Max basically ripped his heart out and left out on the floor, while Donica’s just sort of hunched over and shuffled off stage when his time there was over. Even in Act I, I thought Thaxton was better — he just dripped disdain. I’m glad I got a chance to see Donica, and I hope to see him again in other roles, but for Max, I’d pick Thaxton any day.
lastmidnights said: " …
I am excited to see Marais, since I've heard only good things, but also wish we could have Francis for longer. He is made for this role and this production."
1000% agree. I like Darren Criss, but I wish Francis had taken home the Tony. He’s sensational in this role, and it really says something that he can hold the spotlight so powerfully alongside the amazing Scherzinger. Hope to see him back on Broadway soon.
Updated On: 7/3/25 at 02:58 PM