I am seeing this this coming week and am beyond delighted to read these raves. It is my favorite all time musical. The energy and pure bliss of the last Roundabout concert was, however, something I didn't think had a chance of ever being recreated. These advance notices give me hope.
Many are wondering if this could possibly win best revival over Spring Awakening. This question surprises me as I thought, at least up until now, The Color Purple was the one to beat.
DancingthruLife said:
"I think it's a really exquisite musical. The only thing that leaves me unsatisfied is the ending. I'd been waiting for a grand finale since I understood what was really going on, and it was very early, like two or three songs into the show. However, it ended up, IMHO, quite abruptly and didn't have the level of energy the other parts of the show delivered. I hope in the final version they will fix this, and, if so, will definitely bring friends to the show."
I felt the same way during Ellis's otherwise lovely last revival 20 years ago. (by the way, will Ellis be tony-eligible for directing this revival? I assume so since it's a completely new revival, right?)
Kad responded "Well... the show is being performed as written, and it is not written with a grand finale. They can't and won't change that."
My own feeling is that the problem isn't exactly in the text. It's challenging to make the ending in this show the melt-in-your-heart moment it needs to be. But it's far from impossible. A lot has to do with our expectations of - SPOILER ALERT - just how extraordinarily blissful it will hit us when Georg and Amalia finally unite.
Lightning struck in the concert version. Radnor and O'Hara nailed the final scene! The audience left walking on air. The two stars knew exactly what was required to make the comedy, pathos and desire simmer into the musical ecstasy stratosphere at that final moment. The scene presents an almost alchemical problem for two actors. But from everything being said about all that Levi and Benanti are doing right in this revival, there's room for optimism that lightning can strike twice. As they acclimate during previews, further hone their Second Act arcs and start to really feel each other and the audience in those pivotal but delicately demanding final moments of the show, perhaps they'll find something like the magic that Radnor and O'Hara did.
If not, then, from everything that's being said from the first preview-nighters on this thread, maybe we'll just have to settle for perfection without being transported to ecstasy.
Updated On: 2/20/16 at 08:34 AM