I don't think Roundabout as ever used a pit in Studio 54.
I saw the show tonight. I was in the mezz, to the side, but full view. I was about halfway up, and I thought the sound was fine. I've never seen the show before, and only heard a handful of songs once or twice, so I was by no means an expert.
I LOVED IT. It's such a delight. And having not seen it before, I didn't find it too dated? I think the performances are all very modern. I didn't get that typical musical theater type wooden acting. Everyone was on point. The only song that didn't total land was Michael McGrath's, but I don't think that's his fault.
The set is beyond gorgeous and looks very expensive. Loved the design/lighting. And loved how they accentuated the architecture of Studio 54 prior to the show.
Benati is a revelation. As much as I enjoy Cynthia in Color Purple, I think Benanti really put her stamp on this character. She is just hilarious and heartbreaking and her voice is gorgeous.
Levi was great in the part. He has the right kind of nerdy charm, but you also want to root for him. However, his singing is not my thing. And his big number, "She Loves Me," kind of felt a little forced. The song seems a bit low for him, so I wish he would have spoken it more as the lyrics are quite hilarious and smart.
Everyone else was just brilliant. Jane was hilarious and girl can do the splits. Creel has the best voice on Broadway, and he was great. The entire team was winning.
Ugh, I just wish Masteroff wrote more musicals. Between this and Cabaret, homeboy knows what he's doing. He just writes such quick, cleverly-plotted books.
GO see it.