Finally putting some thoughts together.
We planned a trip to NYC because I wanted to finally see TKAI before Kelli leaves. We had a "When in Rome" moment, and bought discounted tickets to She Loves Me, because we're both big fans of Laura, Jane and Zachary. I've owned the '93 revival recording since it came out, but have always somewhat regretted buying it, because the score never did much for me. Call us superficial, but we bought these tickets to be in the same room as Laura, Zachary and Jane, and for no other reason. We listened to TKAI all week, talked about it, planned our trip around it, and could not wait for it.
As I said in my previous post, the TKAI was good. Not great. The orchestra could have been much louder, Kelli looked bored and talked through several of her songs, and only Ruthie Ann Miles really made an impact (...And what an impact! You own that Tony girl!).
The big, unexpected win of the weekend was She Loves Me...She Loves Me....SHE LOVES ME! I want to scrawl it on every wall I see! What a delight from start to finish. From the overture, which spotlighted several players (each receiving applause), to that gorgeous set, to the abso-****ing-lutely perfect cast, it just ticked every box for sending one directly to musical theatre heaven!
I sat in the front row of the rear mezz, in the center, and only had minor sound problems. The orchestra seemed to be playing in a very restrained fashion, and only overpowered the performers towards the end of "Good Morning, Good Day," when it really gets going, and whenever Jane Krakowski sang. Poor Jane was a bit hard to hear throughout. The set has been discussed much here, and it really is great. It reminds me of a beautiful jewelry box my sister had when she was younger, and I loved the floor.
The show really is driven by the songs, and in a rare occurrence, they all need to be there. Now that I've seen it live, I can't stop listening to the music at home. Maybe this is a show that you have to see to really appreciate? This has been the case for me. Scott Ellis was at the stage door and I congratulated him. He looked pleased in general. I also feel like Paul G. can pick and choose what he wants to do, so he must really love this show to be conducting.
And the cast. Oh the cast! Zachary Levi was almost too good-looking for George, but Boyd Gaines is quite handsome also. Zach was charming, geeky and adorable. His voice is light, but there wasn't a missed note, and I actually preferred his somewhat quiet, maybe dazed take on the title song. Whereas Gaines seems to have been directed to sing it as though he were given a shot of confidence with the knowledge of Amalia's feelings, Zach is playing it as if he really can't believe his good fortune, and there's a humble joy there that I found terribly endearing. McGrath and Jennings are heartwarming, funny, and perfect. While I prefer Brad Kane's voice to Nicholas Barasch's, his overall performance is impressive and just might be remembered at Tony time. Gavin needs to loose the mustache, but he reminded me of Douglas Sills in Pimpernel playing this role. He was a manly-but fabulous fop. His voice really is like "buddah," isn't it? This is also a real grown-up role for him. Oh and Jane.... Those legs...those splits! She's perfection, and though she frequently plays the same type of character, you can not help but love her, and root for her. *Spoiler?* Even knowing what would happen eventually with Kodaly, when she realized what was happening, my heart broke a little. I love her. Period. *End Spoiler?*
And Laura. Laura-GD-Freaking-Benanti. That voice is from heaven. I remarked to my beloved that she seems to possess something like a soprano-belt. She seems born to play this role. Her chemistry with Jane is warm, with Zach it's electric and when she wrapped her voice around Dear Friend at the end of act one, the audience was crumbling with her, while simultaneously eating out of the palm of her hand. If Brantley doesn't write her a love letter, he needs to have his head examined. It seems as if her greatest Tony competition might be Ms. Erivo from The Color Purple, and while I haven't seen the show, if she does indeed take it over Laura, then it must be a performance for the ages, because, if I were the Tony committee, I'd have begun engraving it after Vanilla Ice Cream. It's my favorite female performance I've ever seen.
Are there enough superlatives in there?
I used to post here frequently, but don't much anymore, as I don't get to NYC often, but I had to gush about this show. It's one of the best things I've ever seen (possibly only topped by South Pacific, and the OBC of Hairspray), and as I have time to let it marinate in my brain and my heart, it may surge to the top. I hope it gets glowing reviews, wins a million awards (I know...Hamilton Hamilton Hamilton), and becomes a big fat hit. I will be back to see it before it ends its run and/or this cast is replaced. Please run, don't walk to Studio 54.
"Y'all have a GRAND day now"
Updated On: 3/3/16 at 05:44 PM