I'm with you, to a degree. Putting aside that this was a questionable idea in the first place, I'm a big fan of Taymor's work — as a designer. It's when she puts on her director's hat that she runs into trouble... particularly on big-budget projects where it's almost like she feels she has something to prove to someone. She gets so caught up in "concept" that, as someone wrote earlier, it's like watching something written in a foreign language. Yes, she thinks big -- and thank god someone in professional theatre still does -- but it's always a huge crap shoot. For every LION KING (where you know she was kept on a tight leash by Disney) you have an ACROSS THE UNIVERSE and (sorry to say it, guys, but it's true) MAGIC FLUTE: great big high concept things that sorta visually meander, in spectacular ways, from one SQUIRREL! moment to another. She actually seems far more imaginative when she's working on a smaller scale, when her real skills at ritual theatre can shine through in truly dazzling ways.
I mean, look at it this way: wouldnt a project like SPIDERMAN be better suited to a company like Cirque de Soleil, which has extensive experience in this kind of high-production-values kind of thing?
http://docandraider.com