I saw the show on Saturday night and despite it needing cuts and trims, overall - I really enjoyed it and was impressed at how good the bones were for a second preview.
Everyone's performances felt very lived in and there's some really great stuff there. To me the standouts were LJ, Shoshana, Benjamin, and Ali.
The visual aspect of the show is very impressive - the set is massive, the lightning design is really cool, and the aerial work is really fun. I really loved the way they stage "Belong to Someone" and the first entrance for the Lost Boys.
As I said - the show needs cuts/trims/etc. Before the show, Michael and Patrick addressed us and told us a similar speech to that of what the first preview got - although we didn't have any stops. They joked our performance was "the out of town try out".
Like I said, the bones here are good, and with some cuts and trims - I feel like it will get better.
The "surprise" post curtain scene is really pointless, and definitely should be cut. The Frog Brothers bits definitely need some cuts as they wear out their welcome after awhile. I felt like we spent more time on them than we did with the actual Lost Boys. There's some silly ensemble bits that I thought were fun, but definitely could be cut.
The audience ate this up with a spoon and there were tons of Lost Boys t-shirts and merch being worn in the crowd. Speaking of merch - if you're planning to buy any, definitely use the QR code and pick it up after the show, the merch [and bar lines] were insanely long both before the show and intermission.
I wasn't super familiar with the source material and I'm not generally a horror person [although there's really not a whole lot of horror - more thrills] but I personally think there's a hit here if they commit to making cuts and trims.
I'm already looking forward to coming back later in previews and/or post opening to see how much has changed.
For stage door folks - it was a zoo, but people were good about helping get Playbills to the front for folks a bit further back. By the time I left, everyone had come out [excluding Shoshana] and Paul Alexander Nolan was seemingly the last one wrapping up.
"Anybody that goes to the theater, I think we’re all misfits, so we ended up on stage or in the audience.” --- Patti LuPone.
Updated On: 4/1/26 at 10:22 AM