Here's something I'm missing from all the posts about the previews. (BTW, I'm hoping to see the show in Chicago toward the end of its preview run).
I know the movie very well. It's one of my favorites. In the movie, the character of Michael Dorsey is not a likable character - at least not to women. He first love is acting, and acting ONLY. He does some pretty self-centered things, and proves himself to be an ego-centric cad throughout the move.
Things like:
- He has no steady, romantic relationship with a woman.
- He has no qualms whatsoever about taking a role away from a woman. ...And not just any woman, but a woman who it seems he considers to be a good friend.
- He excuses the selfish action above by telling Sandy that he's doing it for her, so she can star in Jeff's play, but it seems obvious from other scenes that if he's being altruistic at all, it's for Jeff's benefit (because Jeff wrote the play) and for his own, self-serving purposes.
- In the birthday party scene, he hits on EVERY woman present, in the hopes that he can hook up with one of them, but is unsuccessful (mostly because the women see through his superficial come-ons, like the character Christine Ebersole plays in the film).
- Even when he decides to come clean at the end, it's not because he realizes how he's hurting people, but because he doesn't want to be contractually obligated to spend more time masquerading as a woman.
Even at the end of the movie, there can be doubt as to whether Michael and Julie will last as a couple because we, as the audience have yet to see how he will treat her as himself - a man who is still primarily focused on his career.
At the end of the movie we can only see Michael and Julie at the very beginning of their relationship. We don't get the luxury of seeing how his time as Dorothy will effect how he will act differently as a man, in a male/female relationship, or if his time as Dorothy has changed his priorities regarding his work vs. his relationships with women. The movie's ending (perhaps somewhat similar to the musical's if I'm understanding what I'm reading) is not cut and dried regarding Michael and Julie as a couple.
BUT - the movie has one (literal) note of hope. It's the song "It's Telling Me It Might Be You" that underscores throughout the film, and even more importantly, over the closing credits. That one song and its lyrics add the missing ingredient of hope that perhaps Michael has truly changed enough that he and Julie can be successful as a couple.
So far, I haven't heard that there is a song like that in the musical; something that Michael can sing to Julie on that park bench, with literally no other set pieces surrounding them, just the two them at the very uncertain start of their real relationship.
In a way, I think it will be smarter for all if the ending does not get changed or fixed by the end of the preview run. If that happened, there would be less to look forward to for the Broadway run - kind of like a spoiler before the show even opens.
I know I'm more familiar with the movie than the musical, and as I say, I'm hoping to catch one of the final previews. Those of you who have been following the previews so closely, I'd love to hear if you think my notions are incorrect regarding the movie vs the musical, and any other input.
Thanks for all the posts! (I don't mind spoilers)!
Updated On: 9/25/18 at 10:43 AM