Honestly Roger Bart got a nomination for what just might be the hammiest over the top performance ever, that’s far from the best of this or any other season.
Stand-by Joined: 6/18/22
ColorTheHours048 said: "Ptero2 said: "Who the heck is gonna win Featured Actor in a Play? Corey Stoll? Will Keen was the most common prediction I had seen before today, but, well..."
Eli Gelb or Will Brill would be my pick."
I'm gonna bust out the champagne if Gelb wins.
Understudy Joined: 8/22/22
Mark_E said: "I think it's a great set of nominations. That featured actress in a musical category is incredible. What I am very surprised at is all of the love for Water for Elephants. It was by far one of the weakest musicals of the season for me and for it to be nominated for Best Musical and a slew of others was not on my radar."
The critics went to bat for it, out of all things.
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/26/19
Disappointed in so many HK nominations, I thought it was... entertaining and fun, but unoriginal shlock. On the same level as Back to the future. Hurt for Lempicka not getting nominated for the original score and music... At this point I'm just rooting for The Outsiders which I loved and will be getting a ticket to Stereophonic very soon. My curiosity peaked after these nomination got announced.
Updated On: 4/30/24 at 09:47 AM
On the design side, a number of repeated names, with David Zinn and Dede Ayite each getting 3 nominations, and dots, Natasha Katz, and Isabella Byrd getting 2.
Days of Wine and Roses missing in Book and Orchestrations is a headscratcher. Suffs and The Notebook missing in Orchestrations also. Maybe we need to get more experts in orchestration on the nominating committee.
It'll be interesting to see if this has any immediate impact on the box office. I could see The Outsiders and Water For Elephants picking up steam in ticket sales for sure. On the flip side, it'll likely be tough sledding for The Notebook. Gatsby, The Wiz and Tommy have been doing well but I wonder if the lack of noms will slow things a bit. I'm guessing The Wiz will be fine.
Broadway Star Joined: 7/13/04
When Billy Joel won the best orchestration Tony for "Movin' Out," I realized there's not a lot of people who understand what an orchestration is.
Understudy Joined: 6/14/21
The Wiz is a 20 week limited engagement set to go back out on tour. It's also selling moderately well... its future wasn't wrapped up in Tony noms.
Featured Actor Joined: 12/28/21
Quick thoughts:
I'm delighted the Brody gets in. Sad for Chip.
Glad they found five slots for Leading Actress in a Play
Featured Actress in a Musical is WILD and wide open.
No Ricky or Conrad in Featured Actor is probably my biggest heartbreak. Especially with six nominations.
Surprised that Francis Benhamou didn't get in, especially over Quincy Tyler Bernstine, who I was underwhelmed by in Doubt.
Surprised but not mad at all the acting nods or Stereophonic.
LOVE THE WHITNEY WHITE NOMINATION!
Sad that Lorin Latarro didn't get in, especially over Here Lies Love (whose choreo was just meh)
Surprised (but actually not shocked) at Stereophonic in orchestrations.
I love Jaja's in Scenic Design. Surprised at Mary Jane snub.
I sat in the balcony for Hell's Kitchen and the sound design was awful up there. Clearly the nominators sat in the orchestra.
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/26/19
leefowler said: "When Billy Joel won the best orchestration Tony for "Movin' Out," I realized there's not a lot of people who understand what an orchestration is."
It's true. But some orchestrations are glaringly not good, so you kind of recognize these even without special background in music. I thought Lempicka had the worst this year. The Notebook has one of the best orchestration and no nomination for it is baffling.
kurtal said: "I sat in the balcony for Hell's Kitchen and the sound design was awful up there. Clearly the nominators sat in the orchestra."
Maybe that also explains Sweeney Todd's win for sound design last year. I sat front row Mezz and it was truly the worst sound design I have ever heard at a Broadway show.
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/11/16
gibsons2 said: "leefowler said: "When Billy Joel won the best orchestration Tony for "Movin' Out," I realized there's not a lot of people who understand what an orchestration is."
It's true. But some orchestrations are glaringly not good, so you kind of recognize theseeven without special background in music. I thought Lempicka had the worst this year. The Notebook has one of the best orchestration and no nomination for it is baffling."
The breaking point was when Dear Evan Hansen won Best Orchestrations over Great Comet (I actually liked DEH over Great Comet back then, and even I thought that made no sense).
ElephantLoveMedley said: "Stereophonicis officially the most Tony-nominated play in history."
Thank goodness. Now Jeremy can stop touting his mediocre play with that tagline And Stereophonic will actually win some awards.
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/27/21
It's not going to win but considering it started as a one act in a grocery store basement, Gutenberg getting a revival nomination is a nice little cap on that shows journey.
Tony Winner Jeremy Strong has a great sound to it.
Mr.Liir said: "The Wiz is a 20 week limited engagement set to go back out on tour. It's also selling moderately well... its future wasn't wrapped up in Tony noms."
It also happens to be absolutely dreadful.
One thing's for sure about orchestrations: They do love when you can see the musicians.
Broadway Star Joined: 2/21/04
The Wiz deserved a few noms!
Updated On: 4/30/24 at 10:26 AMLeading Actor Joined: 12/9/23
It must be a hard morning in the wiz/brian moreland's office today.
Happy for the HLL love! Surprised by the Lempicka and HK love though.
kdogg36 said: "I can't imagine many shows have won Best Musical without getting at least a nomination for its director."
For the record, it seems that Titanic (1997) is the only show to win Best Musical without a Best Director nomination since the latter category came into being in 1960. Hoping for another one this year.
Broadway Star Joined: 3/29/23
NYT:
The Green Girls are making good.
Three women who have starred on Broadway as Elphaba in “Wicked” picked up Tony nominations on Tuesday.
Shoshana Bean, who inhabited the role for a year starting in 2005, was nominated as best featured actress for “Hell’s Kitchen,” in which she plays a tough-minded single mother trying to protect her adolescent daughter from the temptations of the street. (This is her second Tony nomination — she was also nominated in 2022 for “Mr. Saturday Night.”)
Eden Espinosa, who succeeded Bean as Elphaba in 2006, was nominated as best leading actress for playing an artistically and sexually adventurous painter in “Lempicka.”
And Lindsay Mendez, who became Elphaba in 2013, scored a nomination as best featured actress for portraying a hard-drinking novelist in this season’s hit revival of “Merrily We Roll Along.” (Mendez already has one Tony, for her portrayal of Carrie Pipperidge in a 2018 revival of “Carousel.”)
It’s a good day for The Public Theater, with two musicals that started there now nominated for Best Musical.
Glad to see Grey House remembered for lighting and sound, although I think Joe Mantello also deserved a nomination.
Videos