The Search for Elle THOUGHTS! — Page 57

If Autumn does not win, I will be quite mad. She has the best voice there.

---

Autumn is very talented, but she just doesn't seem right for Elle to me. I wouldn't be upset if she won because she's talented, but, yeah. And her dancing wasn't that good, which could pose a problem.

I don't know why they kicked off Natalie before Rhiannon. Singing chops are a must in my book.

---

I've heard several people (including the judges), say that Autumn is believable as a Harvard law student. She also has to be believable as a Sig Ep sweetheart and president of her sorority, and I don't see that in Autumn. Yes she is talented, but I don't see a lot of "Elle" in her. If I could build the perfect Elle.....hmmmm.
Autumn's acting, Bailey's dancing, Rhiannon's personality, and Lauren's voice. = Laura Bell Bundy!

I agreed with you up until that LBB remark, austengirl. LBB is a bad actress and not a strong singer at all, IMO.

---

If there is one thing I've learned from this show, it's how to count.
"There are five of you left. Four of you still have a chance. One of you is going home. There are two names on the list. That means that three of you are not on the list.
The first name on the list is ______. That means you still have a chance. There are four of you left. That means that three of you are not on the list. That means that one of you is going home."

This is the part in the episode where I start laughing hysterically. If that's what they think is building suspense, I feel very sorry for them.

i couldn't believe how terrible rhiannon's singing was and then bailey didn't show any emotion during the song and then afterwards she was crying because she said she identified so much with the song, what's up with that, go Autumn

i think once the hype of the show is over, the girl who wins will get the boot pretty early and they'll get someone else

Wheni t comes to dancing Elle doesn't really have that much if you think about it; "What you want" and "Positive". So The fact that Autumn isn't that great of a dancer isn't really that big of a deal. I think the singing and acting are two of the more important aspects of the show, Autumn can definitely do both very well. She can work on the dancing, but it's not that big of a deal if she is not an amazing dancer.

Updated On: 7/8/08 at 01:21 PM

Yeah, he did hit some bad notes too. I didn't think Rhiannon was horrible.

I love Autumn too!!!
I want her to win!
Bailey kind of annoys me!
Rhiannon seems like a fun person to be around, but I don't see her as an Elle, at least not yet. She's not a strong enough singer, but I hope to see her in something in the future.
Lauren is great! I don't know if she is ready to take on a role like Elle just yet, but maybe in a year or two! She is going to be amazing!!!
Autumn...just cracks me up!

New 'Legally tuesday" recap on The Ryan O'Connor Show! I think it's funny! Haha


http://youtube.com/watch?v=vnjkSxAfzHE

The Ryan O'Connor Show - Legally Tuesday!!!

My rundown!

I've loved Autumn since day (aka "So Much Better"). I still think she sparkles. Even if she doesn't dance amazingly (I'm NO judge) she does it with so much personality and as someone posted, Elle doesn't dance TOO much. I DO think she can pull off sorority sis well, she's cute and bouncy and kinda quirky. Also, I adore her personality and think it's suited to Elle. Plus, girl can sing. Just LOVE HER.

Lauren - Very talented, AMAZING voice, but her acting isn't amazing. Not bad, I just don't find her compelling.

Bailey - USED to love her but 1) her personality seems annoying 2) she's not good the serious or semi-serious stuff. She needs to play a different kind of role, a Vicki in Chorus Line or Ado Annie in Oklahoma type of deal. Spunky and cute.

Rhiannon - I was really impressed with her acting but surprised they didn't choice Natalie's singing over Rhiannon's presence. If she can't completely sing the role (I don't have much of an ear but could hear this was off) it's further proof she should be Margo, as I've said. Cute, bouncy, sweet, but not quite leading lady yet.

Natalie - Oooh I liked her so mcuh but she was kind of flat acting wise. Yet so was Bailey, and they've both been impressive before, but I guess Bailey had more presence tonight so that's how they chose. Anyone wonder if she misinterpreted Andy Karl's advice and tried to look thoughtful, NOT look angry or sad? I do think she's very talented and hope she goes far. A softer role, perhaps. Can't think of anything at the moment.

Andy Karl: adorable.
And to those who thought they completely chose the Top 15 through dancing, remember the audition reels which are fun to look at. Also, someone somewhere said they think the challenge "who's the worst _" was kind of a test which sounds legitimate. I'm so addicted! AAH!
PS: I'm so glad someone else thinks the title ballad sounds like "Part of Your World"/ "Somewhere That's Green." Tangent: Would Rhiannon make an awesome Audrey or does she not have the voice?

Updated On: 7/8/08 at 11:22 PM

Sorry newbie reverse shills (austen girl) and bobbybubby, (you've recently made it clear that no good can ever come out of your mouth where Andy Karl or his wife are concerned) but you should base it in some reality.

Karl was the only person worth watching in that whole miserable episode and was far from "off" in the singing dept. I could practically hear the groan from the viewing public when Bailey started crying as they cut a quarter of an inch off her mane. Thank GOD Andy Karl was the healthy distraction he was.