Whenever comparing the two, people always talk about the "first listen" which is important when you're seeing a show live. Seeing LaChiusa's Wild Party and hearing it live for the first time as opposed to buying the album and expecting it to strike a chord without an alarming visual, is a tough task - that I think Wolfe did brilliantly. Wolfe is a unconventional director whom many people feel is sloppy and unaware of typical staging techiniques (blocking according to text). Whatever your opinion on the often avant-garde director is, he staged Wild Party with flair and no inhibitions. LaChiusa's score is not even in the same ballpark as Lippa's (greatly superceding the latter), and rightly deserving of the cult acclaim it gets. After seeing it on the Tonys, I knew it was something that most people wouldn't like - and LaChiusa says it best in an interview:
"I think you'll see more of the same thing you've been seeing on Broadway unless we all start dealing with some truths about our culture, which is in decline right now. I wish there was some way for that to be reversed, but I don't know how. I know that my colleagues speak to me in their songs; I feel like they've got a voice that says, "This is a thing of beauty." But it's a larger, more powerful thing that has to go on here. We need a mayor, we need a President, we need religious people to reverse the trend of where we're going culturally. Broadway is a small part of the culture and it's getting increasingly smaller, unfortunately."
This is all too true as far as the success for the show goes and I just thought it would be interesting to just have some of you read that. I digress. Back to the show itself - In LaChiusa's version you feel the booze and you feel the sex in the music and banter of the lyrics. It's real 20's-jazz nightlife. And like Caroline, or Change, Floyd Collins, Marie Christine, My Life with Albertine, etc. much of the music is too complex and not melodic enough for the pop-trained ear to enjoy on a first few listens. I've likened to think that I have tried to rise above it, but each person can only do so much - to have the want to hear, live, and experience new styles of music. LaChiusa is doing his best - which I find to be quite stellar - to go against the grain, but still make audiences laugh and cry. And that's something we all want out of a show.
nice point TWOGAAB - i was writing my thesis as yours was being posted. good thoughts
But I won't live alone in a house of regret.
Updated On: 11/19/04 at 02:14 PM