Broadway61004 said: "I like the cast, but are these really big enough names to sell this show? I mean, yes, they obviously all have their fans, but are the majority of Superman and Heated Rivalry fans going to flock to a 3-person Broadway show that most tourists have probably never heard of?"
Yeah I'm deeply suspicious of their ability to sell this play, especially beginning in the dark days of February. It could be another PROOF or DOG DAY or HUGHIE (2016) situation of vastly overestimating star power.
Each of these 3 people are primarily known to the masses for one thing (Heated Rivalry, Superman, and Handmaid's Tale), and not in a household name kind of way. If you happen to not care about 2-3 of those things, this is an easy pass. Anna Shapiro is also not exactly on a hot streak at the moment.
Corenswet will star in a sports drama opening Christmas day, which got astoundingly high test scores and could be an Oscar contender with crossover potential and a long press tour. Or this could be a whole lot of PR spin.
Updated On: 6/25/26 at 02:53 PM