Jordan Levinson said: "If I'm being honest, Olivo was not one of my favorite parts ofMoulin Rouge!based onclips I have seen. Yes, she's a Tony winner, but she won for a very showy role with some vulnerable acting on the side (what I think is her strong suit). Her Satine started off on the right foot- she nailed the "Diamonds" medley- but her chemistry with Tveit was nowhere to be found. I thought the two of them were good friends and notlovers. She's a good actress and does well with Satine's weaker side, but not really when she's singing- she "oversang" a bit too much of her material IMO.
All this being said, I might consider seeingRouge!live after Tveit leaves. John Logan's book will probably be just as laughably bad asit was last March, but the show overall could easily be much better (and, dare I say it, enjoyable) with a competent, complete Christian/Satine combo.
I will conclude by saying I too greatly respect Olivo and her wise decision. She did what was right for her and I appreciate that. The B'way industry needs to do better dealing withsocial justice, amongother issues such as the Rudin dilemma."
If you really respect someone's decision, then don't make it about you by saying you didn't care much about her performance. This kind of attitude is what is poisonous.
Listen, I don't take my clothes off for anyone, even if it is "artistic". - JANICE