I think people were expecting this show to be another Mamma Mia!
Not realistic. Mamma Mia! has a hetero love story. Actually TWO of them at its core. One for the middle-aged audiences, and one for the younger crowds. It had ABBA songs, which have aged REALLY well, and are popular around the world. Not just with certain crowds or a niche audience. They work well for everybody. And they're popular almost on the scale of the Beatles catalog.
The bottom line is Mamma Mia is clever enough, the book is stronger than most people give it credit for, and the songs are introduced in entertaining enough ways to make people laugh, enjoy themselves, and stay with the story to the end.
It ain't Hamlet. It ain't even Cats. But it works well on its own level. People leave the theatre smiling and very relaxed, almost as if they just spent the past week on a Greek Island cruise. That's saying a LOT. And so many people on these boards have underestimated its universal appeal.
Pricilla (although I haven't seen it) apparently does none of these things, according to the majority of the people who have seen it, audiences and critics alike. (Not me, since I don't count.)
I will say this ... I remember seeing all the clips from Mamma Mia! before it opened. They made me want to see the show, so I went.
I saw the clips from Pricilla, and I thought they were terrible. They made me want to stay away from it. So I did.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22