Encores! Concert Series didn't do it. BC/EFA did in in concert as part of their annual Actor's Fund Concert on September 26, 2005 at the New Amsterdam Theatre.
Here is/was the cast:
Brooks Ashmanskas -- Owen O'Malley
Robert Cuccioli -- Dr. Johnson
Jesse Tyler Ferguson -- Max Jacobs
Cheyenne Jackson -- 'Life is Like a Train' Porter
David Josefsberg -- 'Life is Like a Train' Porter
Andy Karl -- 'Life is Like a Train' Porter
Tyler Maynard -- 'Life is Like a Train' Porter
Marin Mazzie -- Lily Garland/Mildred Plotka
Brad Oscar -- Oliver Webb
Christopher Sieber -- Bruce Granit
Douglas Sills -- Oscar Jaffee
Kathleen Turner -- Imelda
Joanne Worley -- Letitia Primrose
Kim Alvarez -- Ensemble
Phillip Attmore -- Porter
Brad Bradley -- Porter
Todd Buonopane -- Ensemble
Kate Chapman -- Ensemble
Lanene Charters -- Ensemble
Jenifer Foote -- Anita
Robert H. Fowler -- Photographer
MaryAnn Hu -- Agnes
Joe Langworth -- Ensemble
Lorin Latarro -- Ensemble
Mark Ledbetter -- Ensemble
Kristoffer Lowe -- Ensemble
Elise Marie -- Ensemble
Mayumi Miguel -- Ensemble
Naomi Naughton -- Ensemble
Craig Ramsay -- Ensemble
Jermaine R. Rembert -- Ensemble
Charlie Schwartz -- Ensemble
Bret Shuford -- Photographer
Megan Sikora -- Ensemble
Nell Snaidas -- Ensemble
Mary Stout -- Ensemble
Josh Walden -- Porter
Craig Wells -- Conductor Flanagan
Christopher Windom -- Porter
Produced by The Actors' Fund of America; Consulting Producer: Catherine Cooke; Artistic Producer: Seth Rudetsky
Produced on the Broadway stage by Robert Fryer, Mary Lea Johnson, James Cresson and Martin Richards
Book by Betty Comden and Adolph Green; Lyrics by Betty Comden and Adolph Green; Music by Cy Coleman; Additional Orchestrations: Jesse C. Vargas; Concert Adaptation: Tim Pinckney; Musical Director: Seth Rudetsky; Associate Musical Dir.: Steve Marzullo; Based on the plays of Ben Hecht, Charles MacArthur and Charles Bruce Millholland
Directed by Peter Flynn; Choreographed by Denis Jones; Original Broadway Production directed by Harold Prince; Assistant Choreographer: Rachelle Rak
Scenic Design by Paul Weimer; Lighting Design by Jeff Croiter; Costume Design by Rob Bevenger; Sound Design by Scott Stauffer; Hair and Wig Design by Jon Jordan; Props Design: David Masenheimer and Jerry Marshall; Make-Up Design by Make Up For Ever; Associate Costume Design: Jeff Johnson Doherty
Executive Producer: Andrew Kato