I loved the movie. Loved it. That being said...
I agree the timeline seemed a little skewed and gooey. It's always seemed that way on stage, too, though. In the movie the marquee in Las Vegas says 1966, so I'm assuming it's New Year's Eve 1965 into 1966. That makes the Deena/Effie reunion happen in 1974ish. Oddly, though, I think the "I'm Somebody" film Deena watches puts the beginning of the movie's second act at 1973, but I seemed to remember the math not working out in my head. At any rate, that does mean that two years or so pass at times between scenes.
I said this in another thread, but the introduction of a father for Effie and CC really lowers Effie's stakes, and makes it hard to believe that in all those years no one back at the Dreams machine found out Effie had a child.
All the extra nods to the Supremes are either jarring (if you know the backstory) or go over your head (which makes for superfluous filmmaking). Half the people I saw it with didn't realize that that was Michelle being pulled in to be Rainbow's secretary. If the audience isn't making the connection that Effie's replacement came from within, what's the point? It seems the point is that it's simply another nod to the Supremes mythology, because reports state the Berry Gordy did similar things (pulling people off the street like that work for Motown if they had the qualification he needed at the moment).
If it's Deena's, and a case is made in act 2 that it is, then why isn't she more active -- a true player -- in "It's All Over?" I think that's another flaw in the screenplay. The entire scene preceding "It's All Over" is so different onstage and works a lot better, from CC sniping at Deena to Deena storming out of the dressing room. I'm still really surprised that "Wake up, baby, a star is a slave" was cut. I know that it was Jimmy's line and that he was cut from that scene (also a mistake, I think) but I always thought that was one of the most important lines in the show.
"How do you like THAT 'misanthropic panache,' Mr. Goldstone?" - PalJoey