Not since Cameron's ALIENS have I seen such a satisfying sequel. It manages to work in tandem with the first two films -- not a single element fails to track emotionally -- and yet stand on its own. Perfection. What startled me is how moving it is at the very start... Five minutes in...
SPOILER
The opening is fast-paced, as exciting as any teaser in a Bond film. And then we find out it's in Andy's imagination. And we get those home movies of little Andy and his toys, and I was already in tears. And the trick Woody sets up to phone Andy and make him look at the toys is poignant and pitch-perfect. Immediately we know we're in for a desperate struggle between the grip of the past and the necessity of moving on. The start sets the tone for the entire film -- an unsurpassed blend of emotion, thrills, character detail and visual brilliance.
Only Wall-e has come close to this kind of honest manipulation of genuine feeling. The film is the perfect final chapter, and as the NY Times review stated, the three are a meditation on loss and impermannce. The incinerator sequence, much discussed in this thread, as it should be, is daring in its display of -- well, odd for toys -- humanity. It's stunning -- the illustration that this band of plastic and metal and cloth creations are indeed a family who must face their fate together. They are all touchingly heroic in that moment, and it's played with enormous compassion. Is it too fightening for young kids? I don't think so, because the ll o'clock spot with the claw is a breathtaking plot twist that plays off an iconic moment in the first film. Kids will be frightened, but the movie allows them to overcome the fear.
I wouldn't withhold this film from any child who can sit in the theater an hour and 38 minutes. It's wrenching in places -- the one noted above, but always loving and devoid of cynicism. It's earnestness -- daring concept in 2010 -- makes it a one of a kind. It's witty, clever and filled with zingers. But the humor has an underlying appreciation for all "living" things, underscored by the honest depiction of the cylce of life.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling
Updated On: 6/21/10 at 07:26 PM