I swung by the theater and got a Student Rush ticket at 6:15PM. It was Row B of the bowel-cony but I moved down in to a box for the second act.
This was my first time seeing ALNM and have only had exposure to "Send in the Clowns" and "Ev'ry Day A Little Death" from youtube clips of Judi Dench, Maureen Moore & Carol Channing/Ruthie Henshall.
The show was breath-taking and the score was sumptuous as I had imagined it would be. I could have used less of the chamber singers throughout the first act as I felt they served their purpose as 'inner dialogues' best in the second act and really shined in the epilogue reprises. "Ah, well" was an absolute pisser last night.
*SPOILER ALERT - PLOT POINTS* As for the show itself, I have to say (this being my first exposure to the actual plot) I was almost taken aback by the "happy ending." After what felt like a heart-wrenching, yet permanent, goodbye during "Send In The Clowns," I was surprised that Desiree was so willing to play second fiddle to Anne for Fredrik. Perhaps this seemed odd due to the acting choices, but I just felt that the entire play was working up to a great reunion with a regrettable goodbye. For a play riddled with heartbreak throughout almost the entirety of both acts I was surprised to see everyone land in the right place alive, well and in love with the correct partner. I was hoping at the very least to see Charlotte slap Magnus and leave him after being freed of her contemptuous relationship. Also, I love Leigh Ann Larkin and was happy she had her chance to vocally shine, but where the hell did The Miller's Son come from? That wasn't even leftfield, that came from the Grand Central Parkway.*END SPOILERS*
The performances from the leading women were magnificent. With the number of concert tours and stuffy benefits Peters has done in the past decade it would be easy to forget what a gifted comedic actress she is which is one place that she truly shined and surprised me in last night. Her "Clowns" was, of course, revelatory and had the audience enraptured. For whatever reason, the moment I found tears truly streaming down my face was when the song had ended and she slowly creeped off the stage. It was haunting and heartbreaking.
Strichy was a hoot and as much as I thought her crass tone was possibly ill-fitted for a show with more classical grader, it was the perfect balance to the more somber themes and players in the cast. As stated somewhere else, the presence of these two women has truly elevated the cast and you can see it in the fervor for which they all attack these roles.
Not having seen the show until now, I don't have a means of comparison for Herdlicka & Mallory but I did enjoy their performance, although they did feel a bit caricatured. They played the emotions of their respective characters (somber/melancholy & flighty ingenue) to their extreme which worked but were their plot line to require any longer scenes I'm sure I would have found them grating by the end of the show.
As I stated above, I have watched clips of Maureen Moore's Charlotte and was so impressed therefore setting a fairly high bar for her Grey Gardens castmate Erin Davie to surpass. Davie was able to intertwine the silent scorn of her Charlotte with stellar comic timing which truly shined in the second act. I wish I enjoyed the way her and Mallory's voices sounded together more, but thankfully Davie has the majority of the singing in "Death."
Aesthetically I found the production to dance the line of feeling indoor and stuffy while bringing the outdoors on stage for the second act. For a rather simple set, I feel that it was serviceable but I do wish there was more decadence brought to the country chateau and more openness to a show that relies so much on lyrical imagery about the "summer's night," the sun setting and the moon rising.
This is definitely a "run, don't walk" opportunity to see some soon-to-be legendary performances.
Updated On: 7/28/10 at 11:06 AM