I was at the show last night. I thought it was absolutely wonderful. This show is in my top 3 favorites for sure, and I really loved this production of it, despite the negative buzz it previously had. Based simply on the opinions I have read on here, the new leads must have elevated the cast, as this company was about as pitch-perfect as I could imagine for this show.
First, as previously stated above, Betsy Morgan was on as the Countess. Other understudies were Karen Murphy covering Mrs. Segstrom for Morgan and Erin Stewart covering Mrs. Nordstrom for Jayne Paterson.
The cast was, to me, exemplary. Even Herdlicka and Mallory seemed very on tonight, and only cartoony when it served to get a laugh. Mallory was especially funny tonight.
The chorus was phenomenal sounding, and the understudies fit with the rest seemlessly. Lazar was hilarious as the Count, and Hanson captured Fredrik perfectly. Larkin was hysterical tonight, and got a tremendous amount of applause for her Miller's Son.
Betsy Morgan was, to my ears, identical in voice to Erin Davie. In fact, if I hadn't been told Davie was out, I would've spent the whole show thinking that Erin Davie looked a bit unlike herself at that performance. To that end, I'm not sure if Davie has been getting closer to this, but Morgan's performance was 100% biting wit. She had a bit of trouble landing the jokes at first (though I thought they were excellently delivered), but then the audience caught up with her and she later brought down the house with her Act 2 humor. She was absolutely stunning in the role and in Everyday a Little Death (which I'm SO glad is back to it's rightful tempo).
Stritch and Peters had the audience in the palm of their hand from the moment they stepped onstage. I have never seen a show with so much applause after lines. The show was stopped countless times while people applauded during scenes. Stritch in particular only had to turn her head sideways to get a laugh. As far as Stritch's lines went, she was nearly perfect. There were a few moments when she took some rather long pauses, but they really appeared to be deliberate. She did drop the line right before the "squatting like Bohemians" one, but otherwise, she had me hanging on every word she said. Peters embodies this role beautifully, and her Clowns is one of the most devastatingly beautiful things I have ever seen in a theatre.
I'm not 100% familiar with the script, but I also think that Hanson may have flubbed a line (though it might have totally been my imagination). He started to say the line about his wife “to boast and complain” in the dialogue before the music starts, and then said something to the effect of “oh hell, why am I talking like such a lawyer?”. Maybe someone on here could tell me if this is in the script or if it was improvised.
Everyone came to the stagedoor except Mallory and Stritch. Everyone was very gracious, especially Peters, who waited while she signed my playbill so I could get a picture with her.
And finally, I witnessed a very interesting thing while waiting at the stagedoor. As I waited for Bernadette to make her way over to where I was standing, I saw a group of people usher an older man over to right across from where I was standing. The man stopped directly in front of me across the railing. I got a good look at him and realized that it was Arthur Laurents. After Bernadette signed for me and for the rest of my section, she and Laurents walked away down 48th street with their arms around each other. I couldn’t believe what I had just witnessed. A miraculous end to a wonderful evening!
"Art, in itself, is an attempt to bring order out of chaos."-Stephen Sondheim