"It's so hard not to compare to the previous performer..
It's okay. You can name her by name.
I was just on BroadwayOffers to find cheap seats...Looks like both are contracted until November 7th (since ther is a "casting notice" saying the cast after that date is TBD)
Eh, I'd rather not. It brings up bad memories! haha!
Erin Davie is miscast - that's all I can say.
Understudy Joined: 9/24/04
Oh, PalJoey, I hope you get to see the show soon - "You Must Meet My Wife" was a true high point. I loved Catherine for the most part, but I always felt that she was working a little too hard for the laughs in that number, resulting in the song not going over as well as it usually does. I don't want to ruin any of her moments/choices for anyone, but Bernadette really restores the song to the hilarious highlight it should be, while totally making it her own. Completely effortless and hilarious. I honestly can't say enough good things about her take on the role... what a triumphant return to Broadway.
Davie's Charlotte has really grown on me. She's definitely gotten better and funnier. Again, I am so glad "Death" has been restored to a more traditional tempo.
Sirius Black-
I wouldn't say Erin Davie is miscast, perhaps misdirected.
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/20/04
3 hours and 10 minutes? Really?
And I thought it was horrifically long when I saw it at 2:55.
All pacing issues were because of Stritch. She is why the show ran so long, lol.
I'm sure that the prolonged applause breaks had something to do with it, as well.
And I'm sure the pacing is already slow to begin with. Yankeefan saw it before Stritch was in the cast.
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/21/06
As Michael Bennett said, Angela had the same trouble when previews began. Now, this wasn't a preview, but the top ticket price is the same as it was in previews.
If you paid and were disappointed, that's your opinion. But if you want a solid performance, don't come to the first performance.
Why? Was the first performance free?
It's running at 3hrs-ish? Wow. This same production in London came in at just under 2:45 when I saw it. It seemed longer, though... Updated On: 7/14/10 at 03:28 PM
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/21/06
Was the first preview free?
Oh, I'm definitely going to see it again with them! I'm just going to wait until the Elaine settles into the role.
"Larkin's accent is West Country."
This prompted me to re-listen to her track on the CD and left me wondering the west of which country?
I really hate when people say you can't judge a performance on the first preview. If they're going to charge $130 to see the show they'd better be damn ready to be judged on it.
^ Amen. Hallelujah! Praise the Lord! Another thing - back in the day a show had maybe 6, 7 previews at the most....now these shows have, what...30, 40 previews BEFORE the official opening. What is up with that?
Well...but, back in the day, nearly every show went out of town. So they had a run of shows to fix and such.
I don't necessarily disagree with the whole 'Charge full price, get full critique' mindset. But I actually don't ever fault the actors for that. I fault the producers. My belief is, 'You charge whatever you want...but my performance is where it is on that night. You deal with the fallout.'
I really hate when people say you can't judge a performance on the first preview.
It comes from an old-school, old-world politeness thing that doesn't exist any more.
Once upon a time, previews were bargain-priced. Theatergoers were, of course, free to say whatever they wanted after the preview, but people were more polite in general then.
Theater professionals, however, considered it a point of honor NEVER to bad-mouth a production after seeing a preview. It was even considered bad form to ATTEND an early preview. Any negative comments you had were to be saved until after opening night. It was a karma thing: You wouldn't want someone to bad-mouth YOUR low-priced early preview, would you? So you didn't bad-mouth theirs.
All that changed when they up-priced the previews. Then the Internet came along, with chat boards.
And that's good, isn't it?
Larkin said on Twitter that her accent is West Country. I am just repeating what she wrote. I am not the productions dialect coach.
You might have done a better job.
I've been through West Country in England. Leigh Ann's accent is about as far from West Country as you can get. Try County Kildare mixed with Ellie Mae Clampett.
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/20/04
Videos