I saw this tonight and was throughly entertained. I think Benjamin Walker deserves the Tony - didn't care for Fiddler. He gives such a powerful performance and commands that stand, and his physical and emotional decent was just beautifully constructed. And the fact that he made the character so damned likable is to be lauded as well.
The design and directed is incredible! I was really impressed. The set is minimal, but always surprises. And the direction is fluid and dramatic.
The big letdown for me was the score. There were hints of the beautiful Spring Awakening score, but the whole thing felt very Michael Friedman (in that the songs were short and had only one melody - no bridges, chorus, etc). I wanted them all to sing more. There were some gorgeous choral moments, but you leave the theater singing some Huey Lewis and the News song instead of the score.
Yorke should be nominated. She is so hilarious and took her part and ran with.
Jennifer D has such a gorgeous voice and thankfully has a few beautiful moments to showcase it, but her character never speaks above a whisper. I just wish we could have seen more of an arch for her.
For as much as this show is touting how it's sexy and violent. The violence and blood were lacking. I wanted more generally scary moments. And the cast is attractive but nothing you wouldn't see at any gym or dance class in NYC, no offense to the ensemble men (Sir Brantly seems like he was crazy horny while writing that review.)