Home from today's matinee. After my drive home, I think I've sorted out my thoughts.
I was very back and forth throughout. There are elements that are fantastic and others that are not. The sets and costumes really are top-notch. I especially love the Cave of Wonders, outside and inside. Costumes were very sparkly, but not to the point of being distracting.
Adam Jacobs is quite good as Aladdin. I love his voice and it fits the songs perfectly. Being a huge ITH fan, I love Courtney Reed. Vocally, excellent, but I wanted her to kick up the enthusiasm. She's playing Jasmine, what should be a great role. Maybe the size of the auditorium made it feel a bit lost, but she could definitely improve the more she plays it. Jonathan Freeman IS Jafar. It's great to hear his voice again in this role. James Monroe Inglehart plays the Genie as I expected, which is fine. I wasn't a fan of this characterization of Iago. He's too slapstick sidekick, and it felt like that was a role created for the youngest audience members to enjoy.
The HARDEST part for me was the three friends. They go back and forth between friends of Aladdin and narrators that come out between too many set changes to tell us what's going on. That's too many "Arabian Nights Reprises." Anytime they come out, the action seems to come to a dead halt. Their scenes are completely unnecessary. Their song about going on an adventure while storming the palace just felt like a waste of time. I know they originally wanted them in the movie, but I'm glad they were cut. The musical would benefit from some snips involving them.
The flying carpet sequence looks fantastic. We had a 45-minute intermission because of a mechanical error, and I suppose it involved the carpet. We had some stage hands partially hidden at the start of the sequence. However, as it took off, it looked great. Now, they need to go back to the original orchestrations for "A Whole New World." The way it sounds in the show now makes the song feel insignificant. I appreciate them trying something different, but it's too subdued.
Overall, it's not bad. It just needs some snips and tightening up. Shorten the opening ("Arabian Nights" is about one chorus and dance sequence too long). Spruce up the book with more lines from the movie to improve where the books lacks.
One phrase came to mind the whole show: "punch it up." It could be a great production.
::bust a move::