Interesting, Betty and Andee. I felt much the same, though at first I couldn't put my finger on what it was that resonated so much with me. I had heard a few of the songs before going in and really liked the rather experimental, unorthodox sounds the show brought forth. Something was there though as I sat amidst this intoxication of the senses that had me transfixed. I was so overwhelmed, in a powerful way, that while it was happening it was a lot to take in. Again, this was a good thing.
The dialogue and songs, in all their vapidness, were gradually taking me to that place throughout the show where the superficiality and the underlying needs of these characters were something I found provocative. It really held my interest. It was the song, "This Is Not An Exit," that really hit me as it wrapped up everything you had just witnessed in such a beautiful, yet still disturbing way.
Throughout the show you are surrounded by these characters who lead superficial, banal existences. They really do just exist.
And then you have this deep and meaningful song, sung by a very disconnected and not so sympathetic character. In fact, you almost find yourself wondering how you can be sympathizing with this guy. It was powerful. Every time I listen to it, I hear something new. Or I glean something more from it. It's like riding one of those classic attractions at Disneyland where every time you experience it you see something new.
I was a double major in university, English and Psychology, and I think my lines of interests are why I find theater so compelling. Psychology plays a major role in what drives human experience, and it's the stories that come from books, plays, and literature that share those stories and experiences. They go hand in hand.
This musical was one of both depth and vapidness. I found it a conflicting, while equally mesmerizing experience.
I understand it will not be a show or story that resonates with everyone. Some won't see it beyond the surface of its story; others will consider any analysis of the deeper aspects of its dimensions pretentious or flat out uninteresting.
Other theatergoers will find it a captivating study. And I'm one of those who loved the experience.
At the end of the day, critics can't be more than who they are. And they speak for themselves as they give their take on things. Some of us will agree with them; some of us won't.
In this particular show, it's possible the characters and their experiences were not sympathetic enough to be examined deeply by some of the critics. Or maybe they just considered it to be too pretentious to be taken there. And I think it was tossed aside. It almost became like, 'You guys thought the controversial nature of the story cloaked in stylish presentation would hook us, but we showed you….it didn't.'
But IMO, there is something deeper. Something below the surface of the blatant superficiality that can very much be examined in this play.
Again, my opinion. And not shared by the majority apparently.
I'm very glad I saw it, and I can attest to the fact that having the window card displayed on the wall of my den, amidst the likes of such classics as Oklahoma, She Loves Me, Fiddler on the Roof, Jelly's Last Jam, Crazy For You and many others, it garners many a comment from my friends and visitors.
And yes, almost as many comments as the Hamilton window card does.
People are intrigued by it.
Best of luck to all involved in this show on their future endeavors.
Updated On: 6/5/16 at 02:32 PM