Poor girl is too old, but bless her heart.
https://www.broadwayworld.com/article/Amy-Adams-Says-Id-Really-Love-to-Play-Elphaba-From-WICKED-20141228
Updated On: 12/28/14 at 12:15 PM
Can't see her as Elphaba. She'd make a good Galinda, though.
If they make it soon they could get Idina Menzel to reprise her role. She's a hot movie property now thanks to Frozen.
Broadway Star Joined: 11/15/13
they're supposed to be school girls right? they're both too old
But what about her age? Is she young enough?
Good question, Bob. We should ask someone who has at least 3 dozen screen names here. But who could that be?
I don't know but this is a great and meaningful thread.
What about Hall of Fame Quarterback Steve Young? Is he Young enough? How about former UN Ambassador and Mayor of Atlanta, Andrew Young. He's 82 so by that age he must certainly be Young enough. Wow, really got me thinking.
Updated On: 12/28/14 at 01:36 PM
If the film version of Rent taught us anything, it's that it's never a good idea to cast the original actors nearly a decade later.
"If the film version of Rent taught us anything"
Life lesson for the day... do your learnin in skool, not at the movies.
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/22/03
Think twice before you poo-poo it.
Broadway Legend Joined: 1/18/12
I can't picture her as Elphaba for some reason.
If Amy Adams is too old - and she may well be - then Idina Menzel is certainly too old.
What about gender-blind casting???
Would anyone make a better Glinda than Liam Neeson? How cool would it be at a crucial point in the story, to have Glinda look at Elphaba and say "I'm off to see the Wizard and if you try to stop me... I will find you... and I will kill you."
Updated On: 12/28/14 at 02:23 PM
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/22/03
NOT WITHOUT MY SISTER'S SHOES.
It helps to read the entire article.
She goes on to say that there's no way she could ever play the role 8 times a week onstage and thinks she'd maybe like to do it for a one night benefit or something where her age wouldn't be an issue.
Without taking this too seriously ... she doesn't have near the vocal chops to play Elphaba. Come on. And yeah, girl's too old!
"It helps to read the entire article."
A good rule of thumb is to never let that get in the way of starting a pointless thread.
When is the holiday vacation over? Taz needs to return to school.
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/16/07
She's a hot movie property now thanks to Frozen.
Source?
Broadway Star Joined: 7/29/12
If Menzel is such a "hot property," why is If/Then doing so badly?
^Again,let's not worry ourselves about those pesky facts.
Can't wait for the kid to go back to school! In the meantime, girl's too old, "No
More" is about dead and all that.
No Amy not gonna happen...you're better off playing Catherine in the Pippin movie.
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/23/11
I love Amy, in fact, she is one of my favorite actresses.
But Elphaba? No. I am longing for the day that they cast great actors in musicalfilms that are great singers too. They exist you know.
Anyone who disagrees, go check Youtube and search for some random "No good deed"'s.
(Willemijn Verkaik, Rachel Tucker, etc). That is such a high level of craftmanship, that can never be done and work on film by someone who isn't an outstanding singer.
Film and theatre are much more alike than one would think. For example I find the filmed version of Billy Elliot much more filmic than the actual film version of les Miserables, which are basically 1 take theatrical performances on set, and therefore I see actors giving a performance trying to be theatrical and struggling with singing, instead of taking me on a journey.
Videos