godlessondheimite said: "10086Sundays said: "If you do end up seeing Andrew Call, he's wonderful. Has a different interpretation of the role, but still very good. He also, by virtue of his look and personality gives off a different vibe than Andy."
Could you elaborate on how Andrew Call is different? I'm very interested in hearing about different takes on a role!"
Sure! Let me preface this by saying, that this isn’t a judgment on the quality of one performance versus the other, since I don’t think that’s fair. There is so much intricate blocking and so many dense lyrics, especially in the first act, that Andrew, and Sean, should he get to go on, will never have the comfort level with the role Andy does. And even Andy can still get tripped up by a rogue shirt, tie, or lyrical stumble. I know they’re all professionals, but that doesn’t make it easy. Either way, they both offer equally valid takes on the role.
Andrew’s Phil is immature, but there’s no malice to what he does. Andrew plays younger than Andy, so his jerkiness seems to come from a place of, one, never being called on his BS, and two, having a sheltered, spoiled childhood. As if he's just drifted through life doing as he wishes, kind of a lost soul in a way, who doesn't come across as deeply hurt as Andy's Phil.
Once the loop starts, he falls apart quicker and is more fearful of what’s happening. Then after “Nobody Cares,” he’s like a kid in a candy store, just having fun, but again, isn't out to hurt anyone. After "Hope" he isn't quite as low, but is as equally lost. In the end, Andrew’s Phil just needs to grow up and have his eyes opened to the world, the way many sheltered kids do. He has tunnel vision and only sees the world as it relates to him, he isn’t willfully ignoring people, he's just never found his place in the world or anything to give his life meaning.
As an aside: Andrew’s comedy, both with the physical aspects and his delivery, is superb.
Andy’s Phil is flat out mean and uncaring. Since he plays older, his jerkiness seems to come from a place of actually setting out to hurt people, not just having complete disdain for them. Once the loop starts, he fights against it harder and for longer. Then after “Nobody Cares,” he’s like a stereotypical frat boy times 100 with no morals or care for who he uses/hurts.
In the end, Andy’s Phil needs a more brutal wake-up call and his rock bottom after “Hope” is more jarring. He needs to learn to value life and the people around him because he’s never wanted to, or at least, because whatever happened to him as a kid that made him this way was bad enough to turn him into the guy we meet in act one, so it takes more to reverse that damage.