Kiss of the Spider Woman would work exceptionally well smaller. I'd also like to see the show reworked into one act. I don't think that Molina, Valentin, The Mother or Aurora should play instruments though. A band of 3 prisoners, plus the Warden should play the insturments. Marta should also be cut since she has little to do. Prisoner 1: Piano Prisoner 2: Percussion Prisoner 3: Violin The Warden: Guitar Gimme Love and some of Aurora's material should be cut to concentrate on Molina and Valentin, but I think that Good Times should be a recurring theme throughout Act 2 giving a sense of irony to the show. I'd also like to hear the title song constantly reprised by the Warden at first and then by the Spider Woman herself.
I saw the scaled down production of Ragtime at the Paper Mill, and I was blow away. While I have never seen a full blown production of the show, I think that more directors should attempt to make thier shows about characters and not the sets.
personally i thougth the scaled down tour of miss saigon that closed a few months back was awesome... and i've seen regional theaters do a great job... makes the musical so much more better... although i do love the spectacle of it...
could a scaled down showboat work? a scaled down titanic? i dont know if thats possible because the sets are characters in the show... but i dont know. interesting to think about what a director might do with that.
John Doyle did a production of ItW in London which I've heard was veyr well-received. I read somewhere that he'd like to revisit the show after Company opens.
I don't understand how you would make Into the Woods more minimalist... there is very little set... and all the characters are all the characters... there is NO chorus to eliminate... and in the original and revival productions the actors doubled... Same with A Little Night Music... there is no chorus to eliminate... except for the five singers... but how would you even do that?... and Floyd Collins IS a minimalist show... there were only 13 or so people in the original cast... the Cabaret revival WAS a minimalist version of the show... with actors playing instruments and eliminating chorus numbers...
Half of Kiss of the Spider Woman works well scaled down... but you NEED the spectacle of his fantasies or else it sorta misses the point... the whole Aurora aspect misses it's mark if it isn't HUGE... obviously my opinion.
"Picture "The View," with the wisecracking, sympathetic sweethearts of that ABC television show replaced by a panel of embittered, suffering or enraged Arab women" -the Times review of Black Eyed