Saw the matinee today....and I agree with most of what's been said already. Count me among those who was very pleasantly surprised by the show. Without a doubt, the best Wildhorn show and easily his best score. There are some nice tunes in there, though there are still a few of his generic ballads that you could swap between any of his shows. Louis Hobson's song isn't terrible, but I agree that it needs to be cut. It grinds the show to a hault, and he's given nothing to do during the song. All he does is stand in place and sing. The only cringeworthy moments in the score for me were the random gospel songs the fat white guy tried to sing. Who thought they were a good idea?
The book is a huge improvement over any other Wildhorn show. For the most part, it avoids a lot of the triteness that his shows typically have. Act 1 needs some serious cutting and tightening, though, as the show doesn't really get going until near the end of the first act. I loved act 2, however, and feel it's pretty solid already. The problem with act 1 was a lack of tension. It felt like, to quote Officer Lockstock, "too much exposition." Once the "chase" plot kicks in, the show really gets moving.
Jeremy Jordan and Laura Osnes are both giving performances that should establish them both as A-list Broadway talent. They've got real chemistry and in a few spots, seriously elevate the material. Jordan's voice is simply outstanding, and Osnes has a really strong voice as well. Together, the two of them are fantastic. I enjoyed Jordan just a little more, possibly because I found Clyde's story slightly more interesting and thought he had a bit more of an arc than she did.
Overall I really enjoyed it, mostly because of the outstanding performances given by the two leads. The preview period can only help them and I think with some tightening to act 1, the show could be really entertaining. I'd be very interested in seeing it after it's frozen to see what changes they make.
Updated On: 11/6/11 at 06:40 PM