Hey all! Hopefully this will be the last of my replies/harangues about this.
All here, love the theatre. I did not say I was talentless or unskilled, but I realized that I would not be able to make a living at it. And, I chose another way to be part of it, and to make a difference (albeit a very very VERY small part of it).
SoRJ, I started investing in the stock market when I was 13--yes, it was $1000 from my bar mitzvah. I started working at 16--I have saved and invested forever--that is how I was raised. Yes, I had good jobs. I started my own business at 30. I am a commissioned salesman for SWAG.--and have been for the past 34 years. It is not my "access to capital", but the life I led. Whereas "most of the country" might be married and have children, I did not have those responsibilities to expenses. More to save/more to invest. And, I was fortunate during 2000-2005 that my business took off--as did the stock market.
I know that ANYTHING I do within the theatre is on the backs of those who create it---and all those people who listed are rewarded for their efforts. They sign on a project KNOWING what they are signing up for financially. And the big creatives (directors/choreographers etc etc), get a percentage.
As a (film) producer, of all people SoRJ, you should know that INVESTORS are the LAST to see any money (except the producers). So all those actors/creatives are paid BEFORE I am. And IF there is anything left, then it gets put aside HOPEFULLY so that the investors can recoup.
And, if those investors did not put up the funds, there would be no rehearsal spaces, salaries, sets, wigs, etc etc NOTHING!--again, I am SO SMALL an investor in all this. But it is the money that greases the wheel. So what do I get out of it?
I get to know (and feel) I am a SMALL part of it. I get to launch careers (im NOT taking credit for the talent). I get to see my shows receive/win Tonys/Pulitzers/Oscars (that I do NOT have on my shelf)---I get to hear my 14 year old niece hum a tune from a show that I invested in.
So yes, I'd like to be compensated for that. You said the union would be "fiscally irresponsible" to use their funds to invest their members money that way. So, I'M fiscally irresponsible and should share the OCCASIONAL success with those who wont/cant take the risk. Again, I get paid AFTER everyone else gets paid. (and the Union suggestion was not something I propose in reality).
People have said they support the theatre by buying tickets--and then explain they get their DISCOUNTED tix--how do those discounted tix help the production? And why is that money that is spent on tix, "better" than the way I spend my money to help the theatre. This whole discussion has made it sound icky/dirty/GROSS to want to make money in an investment. Well, that's what investors do.
But, in the theatre, investors know that it is NOT likely (and that the lawyer previously said didnt even want to do it)--but he feels NO SYMPATHY for us if we lose money (again, NOT asking for sympathy).
Our INVESTMENT/OUR INVOLVEMENT changes lives / brings JOY / etc etc--without the $, you cant complain about a show--because there would be no show to complain about!!
The discussion seems to be about how much is "enough"--and who gets to share in it. That is NOT our place to say. I was going to say that everyone is welcome to participate--but that's not true either. I did not get approached to invest in Othello (or GNGL, or Hamilton, etc etc)--but I have had others.
Btw--thanks if anyone is still reading...
Lastly, I was fortunate enough to invest in three Bway shows in 2024. The first one (beloved by many here) failed to recoup. The next two were/are SMASH HITS--those gains still do NOT make up for the loss of the first show. And, yes, I invested the same amount in all 3. I have invested in a new show in 2025 that seems LIKELY to become a hit. So PERHAPS, once the 4th show starts distributing PROFITS, I MIGHT wind up even.
So, that's "alot" of people who got to create and live their dreams, and find joy--with my SMALL (fiscally irresponsible) investment. My niece cannot hum a tune to my shares of Apple stock.